-
@Siam said in US Politics:
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
The States has a big problem with police brutality, and black men are massively over represented as being on the receiving end of it.
This is where we need stats and data. I've heard Larry Elder and Thomas Sowell and others refute this generalisation and the stats they cite plus their conviction on the matter paints a different picture from the accepted stereotypes
The stats back this up. From memory 27% of people killed by police are black, despite making up 13% of the population. They are over represented.
There's some important discussion they need to have on why that is, and granted racism doesn't tell the whole story, but it does play an important role. And when you take into account the countries awful history with race relations, it's little wonder incidents like this have such a big impact.
-
@Winger said in US Politics:
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
@Crucial said in US Politics:
The bit that confuses me in this Floyd situation is why the cop wasn't arrested 'on suspicion' while they assembled evidence and a case.
Is that not part of the US justice system? It seems to cause a lot of problems and perspectives of inaction when they have to create a whole case with a high level of proof before acting.
I guess that in our system we can prove a prima facie case at a lower burden of proof, then progress from there (I think)To add some context, there were a couple of events that led into this:
- A white father and his adult son jumped in their truck and chased down what they believed to be a "suspicious" looking black man. They shot him in cold blood, and no arrests were even made for months until video footage surfaced online and there was a public outcry.
- A woman in a park in NY took her dog off a leash (against park rules). A bird watcher who was black asked her to put it back on the leash, she got hysterical and said she would call the cops to say an "African-American" man was harassing her (with an emphasis on his race). She then did just that, attempting to invoke racial stereotypes against black men in the hope the cops would come and deal to him.
Then this video came out and I think people have just said enough is enough given once again no arrests had been made.
The States has a big problem with police brutality, and black men are massively over represented as being on the receiving end of it.
The women lost her job and was rounded criticized. I doubt if this had any impact except maybe for mostly out of town thugs looking for any excuse to smash a place up
I think her threatening police brutality on an innocent black man right before a video surfaced of exactly that played a role.
I agree she really copped it. The condemnation of this latest killing has been widespread as well. Most people are sick of this shit and cannot believe it is still happening in their country.
-
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
@Siam said in US Politics:
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
The States has a big problem with police brutality, and black men are massively over represented as being on the receiving end of it.
This is where we need stats and data. I've heard Larry Elder and Thomas Sowell and others refute this generalisation and the stats they cite plus their conviction on the matter paints a different picture from the accepted stereotypes
The stats back this up. From memory 27% of people killed by police are black, despite making up 13% of the population. They are over represented.
There's some important discussion they need to have on why that is, and granted racism doesn't tell the whole story, but it does play an important role. And when you take into account the countries awful history with race relations, it's little wonder incidents like this have such a big impact.
This stuff happens a lot. Anyone remember the Michael Bennett incident?
He had an officer stick his knee in his back making it hard to breathe. Sound familiar?
It all adds up to a general distrust of the police amongst the black community
-
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
@Siam said in US Politics:
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
The States has a big problem with police brutality, and black men are massively over represented as being on the receiving end of it.
This is where we need stats and data. I've heard Larry Elder and Thomas Sowell and others refute this generalisation and the stats they cite plus their conviction on the matter paints a different picture from the accepted stereotypes
The stats back this up. From memory 27% of people killed by police are black, despite making up 13% of the population. They are over represented.
There's some important discussion they need to have on why that is, and granted racism doesn't tell the whole story, but it does play an important role. And when you take into account the countries awful history with race relations, it's little wonder incidents like this have such a big impact.
Wait. What? 73% of people killed by police are not black??
Who are those poor buggers and why don't their lives matter?🤔I appreciate the over represented black people per capita bit, every country has one of those but the black community is also massively overrepresented in homicides. Nobody kills more black men in America than other black men. Police shoot more white people than black each year and police officers report heightened concern when dealing with a dangerous black man because of the inevitable backlash to follow.
Stats based on raw population numbers don't detail the specifics of criminal communities and their circumstances. Who dominates the criminal space and why.There's a lot of killing going on and the cops aren't doing most of it at all.
No way is that kneeling fuckwit anywhere near the norm for US cop behaviour, I hope.
Or, maybe the cops stink. Not necessarily a racial thing - Justine Ruszczyk also lived in Minneapolis 😒
-
@canefan they do mate. Or perhaps they seem to. I'm conscious of some bias at play where the news saturation gives an exaggerated notion of frequency.
Most things in the US are too large to coherently imagine and when I think of the volume of police interactions every day all through the states I'm sceptical of the significance of these individual cases representing a norm.
The cop killing crisis plays out better on tv than on the data of all police incidents, I wonder.
-
@barbarian said in US Politics:
@Siam said in US Politics:
@canefan if he meant the unlawful looters when he said " shooting starts" then that's a reasonable argument right there.
How is it reasonable to suggest looters will be shot? In what country is that an acceptable response to a criminal but non-violent act? If he said looters will be locked up, sure. But instead his poor choice of words causes makes a delicate situation worse.
The fact is America is a deeply divided nation. Protesters taking over a police station and setting fire to buildings in a major city isn't a normal thing. Trump is not the cause of these actions, or this general situation. But at the same time you can't point to much he's doing to make things better.
I worry for the future of that nation.
Just letting you know I'm agreeing with you.
But this "civil disobedience" is not "non- violent".
-
@Siam said in US Politics:
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
@Siam said in US Politics:
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
The States has a big problem with police brutality, and black men are massively over represented as being on the receiving end of it.
This is where we need stats and data. I've heard Larry Elder and Thomas Sowell and others refute this generalisation and the stats they cite plus their conviction on the matter paints a different picture from the accepted stereotypes
The stats back this up. From memory 27% of people killed by police are black, despite making up 13% of the population. They are over represented.
There's some important discussion they need to have on why that is, and granted racism doesn't tell the whole story, but it does play an important role. And when you take into account the countries awful history with race relations, it's little wonder incidents like this have such a big impact.
Wait. What? 73% of people killed by police are not black??
Who are those poor buggers and why don't their lives matter?🤔I appreciate the over represented black people per capita bit, every country has one of those but the black community is also massively overrepresented in homicides. Nobody kills more black men in America than other black men. Police shoot more white people than black each year and police officers report heightened concern when dealing with a dangerous black man because of the inevitable backlash to follow.
Stats based on raw population numbers don't detail the specifics of criminal communities and their circumstances. Who dominates the criminal space and why.There's a lot of killing going on and the cops aren't doing most of it at all.
No way is that kneeling fuckwit anywhere near the norm for US cop behaviour, I hope.
Or, maybe the cops stink. Not necessarily a racial thing - Justine Ruszczyk also lived in Minneapolis 😒
I won't go too deep into this as I simply don't know enough about the States to make informed comments, but I don't think anything you've said there counters what I've talked about. You've just listed a bunch of other problems. All I'll say is the race related problems are always going to be more emotionally charged across the country given the context of their history.
-
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
@Siam said in US Politics:
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
@Siam said in US Politics:
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
The States has a big problem with police brutality, and black men are massively over represented as being on the receiving end of it.
This is where we need stats and data. I've heard Larry Elder and Thomas Sowell and others refute this generalisation and the stats they cite plus their conviction on the matter paints a different picture from the accepted stereotypes
The stats back this up. From memory 27% of people killed by police are black, despite making up 13% of the population. They are over represented.
There's some important discussion they need to have on why that is, and granted racism doesn't tell the whole story, but it does play an important role. And when you take into account the countries awful history with race relations, it's little wonder incidents like this have such a big impact.
Wait. What? 73% of people killed by police are not black??
Who are those poor buggers and why don't their lives matter?🤔I appreciate the over represented black people per capita bit, every country has one of those but the black community is also massively overrepresented in homicides. Nobody kills more black men in America than other black men. Police shoot more white people than black each year and police officers report heightened concern when dealing with a dangerous black man because of the inevitable backlash to follow.
Stats based on raw population numbers don't detail the specifics of criminal communities and their circumstances. Who dominates the criminal space and why.There's a lot of killing going on and the cops aren't doing most of it at all.
No way is that kneeling fuckwit anywhere near the norm for US cop behaviour, I hope.
Or, maybe the cops stink. Not necessarily a racial thing - Justine Ruszczyk also lived in Minneapolis 😒
I won't go too deep into this as I simply don't know enough about the States to make informed comments, but I don't think anything you've said there counters what I've talked about. You've just listed a bunch of other problems. All I'll say is the race related problems are always going to be more emotionally charged across the country given the context of their history.
That's true, I have. But I don't think skin colour alone counts for these disparities. I question if these "patterns" are due to race primarily and not other socio-economic behaviours.
But you didn't say that and I have little to quibble about your opinion. 👍
Race related problems are more emotionally charged, true, but I don't think these problems are unique to race. Racial analysis is only skin deep. These issues are way more complex and race is the least defining explanation for USAs social ills. The only conclusion to " it's all racist" is to find a dead set blatant racist heading the system with directives in kind. These are never found despite repeated insistence of systemic racism. Black police chiefs dominate police forces in the states, but yet these issues seem to continue.
Behaviour and circumstances rules the criminal space in all countries, not merely skin pigment.
Coleman Hughes caused me to reconsider the popular narrative. Here's an example of his writing
-
More and more it's looking like Antifa is responsible for starting a lot of the violence at the protests. Lots of black people on Twitter talking about it, with footage to back up what they are saying.
-
@Siam Coleman Hughes is fantastic. Another person worth looking up is Chloe Valdary who is in a similar mould. A real voice of reason.
-
@No-Quarter said in US Politics:
More and more it's looking like Antifa is responsible for starting a lot of the violence at the protests. Lots of black people on Twitter talking about it, with footage to back up what they are saying.
Yet the actual Mayor of Minneapolis refuses to call out this obvious point, that this is LEFT wing violence.
It's those dastardly white supremacists again - they hate it so much when a white cop kills a black man that they riot.
-
@Frank said in US Politics:
Yet the actual Mayor of Minneapolis refuses to call out this obvious point, that this is LEFT wing violence.
Why on earth does it matter how the protestors might vote? This is a big part of the problem, people just view this through whatever political prism they choose to.
The truth is it's a multi-faceted problem with many causes and no easy solutions. Republicans and Democrats share blame equally.
But as long as people see this as either 'dirty left wing protestors' or 'corrupt right wing MAGA cops' then this problem is just going to keep getting worse and worse.
-
@barbarian said in US Politics:
@Frank said in US Politics:
Yet the actual Mayor of Minneapolis refuses to call out this obvious point, that this is LEFT wing violence.
Why on earth does it matter how the protestors might vote? This is a big part of the problem, people just view this through whatever political prism they choose to.
The truth is it's a multi-faceted problem with many causes and no easy solutions. Republicans and Democrats share blame equally.
But as long as people see this as either 'dirty left wing protestors' or 'corrupt right wing MAGA cops' then this problem is just going to keep getting worse and worse.
...and a president that stirs up divisiveness.
Next problem will be because of this......https://amp.usatoday.com/amp/5283349002?__twitter_impression=true
“Qualified immunity”.
I get the concept but in practice this is seriously fucked up and if this cop gets off under this the next round will start. -
@barbarian
Its important the public know who is doing the rioting.This is left wing violence.
To a certain extent, these left wing rioters are emboldened because the people in charge are so afraid to be heavy-handed because "police brutality" will be their rallying cry if they are dealt with severely (which they should be)
I would be looking to protect people's businesses and livelihoods and showing no mercy with this scum.
US Politics