The Silver Fern

    • Register
    • Login
    • Search
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Users
    • Tipping
    • Thread Topics
    • Highlights
    • Team Sheets
    • NPC Results
    • Upvote Leaderboard
        • TSF
        • Home Page
        • Browse Posts
        • Tipping
        • Tipping Home
        • Submit Your Tips
        • Current Tips
          Rugby Info
        • Team Sheets
        • Highlights
        • Rugby Results
        • AB Results
        • SR Results
        • NPC Results
          Forum Links
        • Leaderboard
        • Popular Topics
        • Topic Tags

    Solar Power - Help Needed

    Off Topic
    4
    11
    196
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Victor Meldrew
      Victor Meldrew last edited by

      Starting this thread as I need some advice and recall there's some experts on The Fern...

      Installing solar power (6kWh system with battery storage) and an getting a bit confused on choosing the right type of battery.

      Been quoted £2,500 for a 8.2 kWh battery which is AC coupled and uses LiFeP04 tech and:

      £5,500 for a 10kWh battery, DC coupled and which uses NMC tech.

      The question I have is why the huge price difference and do the advantages of the DC coupled battery outweigh the costs? I should add I'm really not too worried about the capacity difference (but wonder if I should be).

      I understand how the electrical/electronics stuff works, but am a complete newbie when it comes to the tech in the real world so any input would be great.

      NTA 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
      • Crucial
        Crucial last edited by

        Sounds like one for @NTA

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
        • NTA
          NTA @Victor Meldrew last edited by

          @victor-meldrew said in Solar Power - Help Needed:

          Been quoted £2,500 for a 8.2 kWh battery which is AC coupled and uses LiFeP04 tech and:
          £5,500 for a 10kWh battery, DC coupled and which uses NMC tech.

          Quite a difference. It depends on a variety of factors, but in short:

          • NMC has higher energy density, is a bit fussier about operating conditions, and with Cobalt involved will cost more
          • LiFePO uses more plentiful materials, has a wider operating temperature, but trades that off (generally) in size of unit per kWh

          After that it comes down to manufacturer, warranty, and usable kWh i.e. my Powerwall v1 had 6.4kWh of storage but only 6.0kWh usable at start of life.

          Make sure the installer is quoting you usable capacity as a first step.

          Whether it is DC or AC coupled doesn't make a huge difference, just a bit of efficiency loss in AC compared to DC coupled.

          Victor Meldrew 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • Victor Meldrew
            Victor Meldrew @NTA last edited by

            @nta said in Solar Power - Help Needed:

            @victor-meldrew said in Solar Power - Help Needed:

            Been quoted £2,500 for a 8.2 kWh battery which is AC coupled and uses LiFeP04 tech and:
            £5,500 for a 10kWh battery, DC coupled and which uses NMC tech.

            Quite a difference. It depends on a variety of factors, but in short:

            • NMC has higher energy density, is a bit fussier about operating conditions, and with Cobalt involved will cost more
            • LiFePO uses more plentiful materials, has a wider operating temperature, but trades that off (generally) in size of unit per kWh

            After that it comes down to manufacturer, warranty, and usable kWh i.e. my Powerwall v1 had 6.4kWh of storage but only 6.0kWh usable at start of life.

            Make sure the installer is quoting you usable capacity as a first step.

            Whether it is DC or AC coupled doesn't make a huge difference, just a bit of efficiency loss in AC compared to DC coupled.

            Cheers, that's great and just the info I needed.

            It was the price difference which grabbed me and your info has helped. Think the more expensive unit (SolarEdge) is being sold on looks and size - neither of which is a major issue for us.

            Magpie_in_aus NTA 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • Magpie_in_aus
              Magpie_in_aus @Victor Meldrew last edited by

              @victor-meldrew sounds like me at 3am at a bar. Looks and size don't worry me too much.

              Victor Meldrew 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 6
              • NTA
                NTA @Victor Meldrew last edited by

                @victor-meldrew said in Solar Power - Help Needed:

                Cheers, that's great and just the info I needed.
                It was the price difference which grabbed me and your info has helped. Think the more expensive unit (SolarEdge) is being sold on looks and size - neither of which is a major issue for us.

                Ah right - I have a SolarEdge inverter and battery management system hooked up to the Powerwall.

                Israeli company I'm told. So far, so good (will be 6 years by end of this month), but I believe they market themselves as "premium", so that might explain it.

                From left: battery (duh), then the BMS, then the inverter (5kW).

                79c964ad-db03-4a8d-b24c-12abaed0f167-image.png

                Basically this was the only inverter on the market at the time that fit the Powerwall.

                It also came with power optimisers (also mistakenly called micro-inverters which are a slightly different thing), that control and monitor each panel individually rather than a single string. So the cheaper Chinese Tier 2 panels I ended up with are still quite performant.

                What is the brand of the LiFePo battery?

                Victor Meldrew 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                • Victor Meldrew
                  Victor Meldrew @NTA last edited by Victor Meldrew

                  @nta said in Solar Power - Help Needed:

                  Good info on the BMS & inverter - thanks Something else for me to get to understand and consider. At the end of the day it's a cost/value equation over 10 years.

                  What is the brand of the LiFePo battery?

                  GivEnergy 8.2kWh

                  GivEnergy 8.2kWh LiFePO4 Battery

                  GivEnergy 8.2kWh LiFePO4 Battery

                  Renugen solar panels wind turbines

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                  • Victor Meldrew
                    Victor Meldrew @Magpie_in_aus last edited by

                    @magpie_in_aus said in Solar Power - Help Needed:

                    @victor-meldrew sounds like me at 3am at a bar. Looks and size don't worry me too much.

                    My mate in Newport talks about The Magic Bus.

                    It arrives when your in the pub loo after the 3rd pint and whisks away all the average-looking and ugly women and replaces then with gorgeous-looking women wearing the same clothes and hair....

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 4
                    • NTA
                      NTA last edited by NTA

                      @victor-meldrew have a read of this:

                      Kerry Thoubboron  /  May 26, 2021

                      Comparing Microinverters and Power Optimizers | EnergySage

                      Comparing Microinverters and Power Optimizers | EnergySage

                      Microinverters and power optimizers are two of the more popular inverter technology options. Learn how the compare.

                      Micro Inverters aren't necessarily better than Power Optimisers - just depends on the engineering of the system as a whole.

                      So basically you have three differences in how the panels operate:

                      Basic string - where some or all panels are on one circuit that feeds back to the inverter. This is how they used to do it in the old days, when people were getting 6-8 panels on one roof space. The issue is if one panel stops performing (breakage, intermittent shade, etc) it affects the whole array. Once systems got bigger you'd have multiple strings and so on, or if you had panels in different orientation, or needed to balance voltage.

                      With optimisers or microinverters you don't need to worry about any of that - one or more panels get shaded, the rest just power on.

                      Victor Meldrew 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 2
                      • Victor Meldrew
                        Victor Meldrew @NTA last edited by

                        @nta

                        Brilliant. Thanks

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                        • Victor Meldrew
                          Victor Meldrew @NTA last edited by Victor Meldrew

                          @nta said in Solar Power - Help Needed:

                          @victor-meldrew have a read of this:

                          Kerry Thoubboron  /  May 26, 2021

                          Comparing Microinverters and Power Optimizers | EnergySage

                          Comparing Microinverters and Power Optimizers | EnergySage

                          Microinverters and power optimizers are two of the more popular inverter technology options. Learn how the compare.

                          Micro Inverters aren't necessarily better than Power Optimisers - just depends on the engineering of the system as a whole.

                          So basically you have three differences in how the panels operate:

                          Basic string - where some or all panels are on one circuit that feeds back to the inverter. This is how they used to do it in the old days, when people were getting 6-8 panels on one roof space. The issue is if one panel stops performing (breakage, intermittent shade, etc) it affects the whole array. Once systems got bigger you'd have multiple strings and so on, or if you had panels in different orientation, or needed to balance voltage.

                          With optimisers or microinverters you don't need to worry about any of that - one or more panels get shaded, the rest just power on.

                          On the same technical wavelength as the designer now and system set-up pretty much sorted.

                          Once again thanks for the help.👍

                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                          • First post
                            Last post