@African-Monkey Brooke-Cowden definitely deserves to be in there. I'd bracket him with Papali'i because Papali'i had one of the best seasons I've ever seen by an openside at school level.
Forgot about Hodgman. I might give him the edge over Lindenmuth.
I thought about David Smith, but left him off because the other options looked good enough. He was really dominate at 1st XV level though.