Gold Coast Comm Games
-
@canefan said in Gold Coast Comm Games:
@chris-b said in Gold Coast Comm Games:
Nasty.
Reality of her lifting with the women is that she was in her own competition anyway - her first lift was 7kg more than the best lift of the next best competitor.
How do you deal with all this if you're a sports administrator?
I reckon you allow transgender athletes and blade-runners etc to compete with the other athletes, but you have extra medals. e.g. If Laurel wins overall then she gets a gold, but so does the first natural born woman. If she comes second she gets a silver, but so does the person who comes third. If she comes fourth she gets nothing - like everyone else.
Participation medal. Nice
For whom?
-
-
-
@chris-b said in Gold Coast Comm Games:
@canefan said in Gold Coast Comm Games:
@chris-b said in Gold Coast Comm Games:
Nasty.
Reality of her lifting with the women is that she was in her own competition anyway - her first lift was 7kg more than the best lift of the next best competitor.
How do you deal with all this if you're a sports administrator?
I reckon you allow transgender athletes and blade-runners etc to compete with the other athletes, but you have extra medals. e.g. If Laurel wins overall then she gets a gold, but so does the first natural born woman. If she comes second she gets a silver, but so does the person who comes third. If she comes fourth she gets nothing - like everyone else.
Participation medal. Nice
For whom?
I don't think Laurel should be able to compete against biological women. It puts her in a difficult situation because who can she compete against? Medals for Laurel and medals for everyone would be a very PC way to go
-
-
@canefan Probably not, but that's seemingly what we're stuck with. Oscar Pistorius was heading in a similar direction.
That's why I think my solution is a reasonable compromise. She gets to compete as a woman, but doesn't deprive someone else of their deserved reward.
Won't work in contact sports.
Edit: And they give away so many medals in swimming it's not like a few more are going to make much difference.
-
-
@chris-b said in Gold Coast Comm Games:
What did the English girl think had happened a couple of points from the end when she caught the ball?
Critical error!
Just made a fuck up and tried to bluff her way to winning the let.
She reminded me of one or two of the teenagers who can’t control their temper at the local club when shit doesn’t go their way.
-
The swimming is an outlier. There should be two medal tables, one with and one without swimming. Just completely distorts things.
