2018 New Zealand U20s
-
@stargazer he wasn't penalised and rightly so. Nobody told the Welsh player to jump for no reason
-
@rebound said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
@stargazer he wasn't penalised and rightly so. Nobody told the Welsh player to jump for no reason
True.
But if that's what passes for a tackle in NZ then heaven help us
-
@mikethesnow heaven help us if players start jumping to catch a pass and draw penalties...
-
@mikethesnow it wasn't a tackle but competition for the ball. It really is a grey area that was highlighted during the recent Lions tour. It might be cynical of me but I'm sure this would've been clarified by now had it been Faumuina who had jumped for the ball when he didn't have to.
-
@mikethesnow said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
@rebound said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
@stargazer he wasn't penalised and rightly so. Nobody told the Welsh player to jump for no reason
True.
But if that's what passes for a tackle in NZ then heaven help us
delightfully pissy and dramatic
-
@mikethesnow said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
@rebound said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
@stargazer he wasn't penalised and rightly so. Nobody told the Welsh player to jump for no reason
True.
But if that's what passes for a tackle in NZ then heaven help us
There is an argument that the welsh player went into contact with the knee raised, yellow card for dangerous play
-
@taniwharugby said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
@mikethesnow heaven help us if players start jumping to catch a pass and draw penalties...
When would that happen?
-
-
U20 Championship 2018: Disciplinary
Tanielu Tele'a (New Zealand)
New Zealand centre Tanielu Tele’a appeared before an independent Disciplinary Committee (Charles Cuthbert (UAE) chair, former Scotland player Beth Dickens and former Scotland and Edinburgh coach Frank Hadden) in Perpignan on 5 June, 2018 having been cited by Citing Commissioner Eugene Ryan (Ireland) for a late, dangerous tackle and/or strike on Wales centre Ioan Nicholas in breach of Laws 9.11-9.13 in the 81st minute of their Pool A match at the World Rugby U20 Championship on 3 June ,2018 in Béziers. Tele’a accepted that he had committed an act of foul play but disputed that the Citing Commissioner was correct to determine that it warranted an ordering off. Having received evidence from Tele’a, referee Ludovic Cayre (France), a medical report and a statement from Nicholas as well as reviewing the video footage and hearing submissions on behalf of the player, the Disciplinary Committee determined that Tele’a had led with his shoulder and recklessly struck Nicholas’s head. The Committee upheld the citing under Law 9.12 and considered it to be mid-range offending which carries a six-week entry point. They reduced the sanction to three weeks based on Tele’a’s youth and inexperience, previously clean record, conduct, remorse and acceptance that he had committed foul play. During the tournament three weeks equates to three matches. Tele’a is suspended for New Zealand’s remaining three matches in the World Rugby U20 Championship 2018. The player has 48 hours in which to appeal. The full written decision will be published here when available. -
I wonder whether teams are permitted to fly in a replacement for a player who has been suspended for the remainder of the tournament. Does anyone know? I guess, if it's permitted and if they want to replace Tele'a, Ngane Punivai will get a phone call.
-
@rapido said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
Telea has been suspended, 3 games, that's his tournament.
Incident we've all been talking about?
If so, the citing commission may have had a different angle to look at.
Rewatching it the NZ player totally misjudged both the flight and bounce of the ball and clumsily made contact with the Welsh player with his shoulder.
That's my 2 cents.
-
@mikethesnow No, it's a different player and a different incident from the one in the clip that I posted (that was from the first half and the player was Leicester Faingaanuku). The suspended player is Tanielu Tele'a, who was yellow-carded for a late, no-arms tackle at the end of the game (81st minute). Really stupid and unnecessary, and obviously, the citing commissioner and the Disciplinary Committee considered it a red-card offence instead of a yellow.
-
@stargazer said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
@mikethesnow No, it's a different player and a different incident from the one in the clip that I posted (that was from the first half and the player was Leicester Faingaanuku). The suspended player is Tanielu Tele'a, who was yellow-carded for a late, no-arms tackle at the end of the game (81st minute). Really stupid and unnecessary, and obviously, the citing commissioner and the Disciplinary Committee considered it a red-card offence instead of a yellow.
Ta
-
@stargazer said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
@cgrant This is the link to the game on TVNZ On Demand. You'll need to register.
Thanks a lot !
-
@stargazer said in 2018 New Zealand U20s:
The suspended player is Tanielu Tele'a, who was yellow-carded for a late, no-arms tackle at the end of the game (81st minute). Really stupid and unnecessary, and obviously, the citing commissioner and the Disciplinary Committee considered it a red-card offence instead of a yellow.
Yes, late body check with the shoulder after the player had passed. But something collected with the Welsh guy's chin. I think it was Telea's head.
So, basically in mitigation I think he accidentally head butted him but while committing a cheap, late foul. So, no bother for me with the suspension. I can't tell from reading the above if the judiciary saw it the same way I did, but even if they did I'd guess the fact it happened while committing a foul means mitigation, schmitigation.
Welcome to televised rugby Taneila. What you could do to an e.g. skinny Roskill Grammar midfielder in a non-televised first XV match no longer applies.
-
https://www.tvnz.co.nz/shows/world-rugby-u20-championship/episodes/s2018-e4