Springboks vs All Blacks 2
-
@antipodean yep, and not talking to Akira to keep him in NZ has backfired so badly it's not even funny, the cupboard is completely bare at 6 right now.
-
@antipodean I'm not arguing that it was a great selection, I'm on record numerous times criticising it.
I just don't understand the argument that he had plans for the back row and the Crusaders being shit changed them - he still selected Blackadder despite fuck all games - I criticised that decision, but he's done well. He didn't select Hoskins, who was the form player. I criticised that one too.
So what did he change because the Crusaders were shit? Literally the only thing I can think of is not selecting Grace, and that is no game-changer.
It's the selection of Jacobson, Cane, Papalii (particularly), with Savea and Blackadder together that is fucked. One crusader, 2 chiefs, 1 ex-hurricane, 1 blue. And Blackadder has been the best of the lot. And Cane and Savea weren't form selections. If anything I think he had plans already made and stuck to them, despite Super form. -
@Snowy said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
@Billy-Webb said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
@Snowy said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
@voodoo said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
@Brandon said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
Just an apology from SA Rugby over the timing issue with flyover etc.
Best wishes
BI mean…very generous…but also - it’s also a bit embarrassing to think that some of us kiwis are genuinely upset about this - its a fucking A380, it’s kinda hard to time and manoeuvre perfectly!
All seems a bit precious to me
" its a fucking A380, it’s kinda hard to time and manoeuvre perfectly! "
Um, no it's actually really easy, and happens at pretty much every arrival into every airport, but your point about preciousness remains!
And if anyone on this forum would know, it's you Snowy.
Not sure the game management had thought of being in direct contact with air traffic control though... And if they were, the bloomin DJ probably drowned out their comms anyway.Good to see you around Billy, about time I headed over your way again!
Would be super happy to host you anytime you're ready Snowy.
I'll have the chilli-biltong on standby.
(and maybe one or two bottles of red wine too...) -
@Jet said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
Story of the season is surely Blackadder casting off his niggles moniker by being an 80 minute week in week out tyro.
WPOTY incoming. 😀
Seriously, WTF do people see in Blackadder.
INMHO, he's softer in defence than the complaints about Ardie, haven't seen a good solid driving tackle or big hit from him yet.
He's useless with ball in hand and makes little real yards and then clearly his decision making is farking shite given the ball hungus screwing the pooch on a certain try!
Sure, he has an engine and runs all game and is involved but his involvment lacks much impact on both sides of the ball.
Fark me, I honestly watch his game scratching my head and think, "WTF are the coaches seeing in this guy?"!
In terms of changes, I think we clearly need more height in the engine room, start Darry and move Vai'i to starting 6. More height, more grunt!
-
Maybe we don't have the right depth, the right selection, good enough players, the best possible coaching.
Or maybe it is an onfield leadership problem. -
@BorderJB said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
…and outside him ALB as a non playmaking 12
That’s exactly what the ABs back line needs, said no one ever
-
@RoninWC That's just nonsense.
He makes heaps of tackles. Gets off the deck quickly and helps reorganise the defensive line. By your logic, someone like Motu Matu'u is more valuable than Richie McCaw.
He makes a decent number of carries. Far more, and far more effectively than Cane, DP, LJ. So if you're gonna rubbish him, you ought to deal out harsher criticism to most of his alternatives.
He gets to a lot of rucks.
A workaholic loosie with a big motor is nothing to be sniffed at. Might not be much of a highlights reel, but the work still has to be done. -
Blackadder rarely wins collisions against other forwards whether it's in the carry, in the tackle, or at the breakdown.
He's got workrate but he's a very low impact player and outside of props I think he would have the lowest top speed in the squad.
-
@brodean said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
Blackadder rarely wins collisions against other forwards whether it's in the carry, in the tackle, or at the breakdown.
He's got workrate but he's a very low impact player and outside of props I think he would have the lowest top speed in the squad.
Rubbish he has had 2 good test matches in a row one of the better performers.
This BS on Blackadder is tiresome when there is a few other players who deserve the spotlight for shit performances. -
@brodean said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
Blackadder rarely wins collisions against other forwards whether it's in the carry, in the tackle, or at the breakdown.
He's got workrate but he's a very low impact player and outside of props I think he would have the lowest top speed in the squad.
Pick a team full of big hitters who are slow to get off the ground and make half a dozen tackles per game and see how you go.
Pick a team full of Doug Howlett and see how you go. -
@brodean
I was feeling shit on Sunday Morn, decided to watch a replay cos I could and tried to concentrate on Blackadder only.
Mainly remember his defence. Maybe he attacked but can’t remember much apart from screwing CC, who was not happy and told him so.
Blackadder made a huge amount of tackles and “hit” a lot of rucks. Sometimes he would do 2-3 in a row, getting up and going again. Was crazy how many rucks he was at.
But, most of the tackles were “absorbing”. He would get the guy down but rarely pushed them back, made a good hit or put pressure on apart from being there. That could have been the next guys job?
He tried to release and steal about 1/3 of the time if he was in position, but got cleaned out most times and never succeeding that I saw. But was annoying as, at the ruck.
Is that his job? Just be in the way, create a bit of chaos?
The one dominant tackle I saw was on our line vs Koch I think, No 18. Great timing and hit him hard but didn’t result in anything.
I like Blackadder, but as a former fullback/wing I have zero idea if the above is effective forward play at test level or not.
In comparison, Cane hit less but smashed people. -
@DMack I'd compare to something like Perenara getting to more breakdowns etc on time, but then fucking up the distribution as compared to Ratima who might be a bit slower getting there but aces the distribution. There's plenty who don't like that aspect of Perenara's play but give Blackadder a pass.
-
Yes I've already said he had a good workrate.
PsDT, Kaino and Juan Smith all had good workrates but they hit hard and thats the difference. These are the last three blindsides to win World Cups. Do you honestly believe that Blackadder has the upside of these players?
He's never going to be a world class blindside. There are players in NZ with the potential to be that. Finau certainly has the athletic ability he just needs some consistent opportunity and guidance. He did well enough against England and should have been persevered with.
-
Just been given the backline for this weekend below. Again, this contact hasn’t led me astray before so very reliable. Very very surprised by some choices and the amount of changes which makes you question the accuracy but fuck it, hasn’t been wrong yet so yeah sharing with the fern. Caleb Clarke is out injured.
- Ratima
- Dmac
- Telea
- J.Barrett
- Ioane/ALB(this isn’t yet decided)
- Reece
- Jordan
Bench
21. Perenara
22. B.Barrett
23. Couldn’t quite hear the name or whatever was said there unfortunately, I’m guessing whoever isn’t selected at 13 so either Ioane or ALB. -
@brodean said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
Yes I've already said he had a good workrate.
PsDT, Kaino and Juan Smith all had good workrates but they hit hard and thats the difference. These are the last three blindsides to win World Cups. Do you honestly believe that Blackadder has the upside of these players?
He's never going to be a world class blindside. There are players in NZ with the potential to be that. Finau certainly has the athletic ability he just needs some consistent opportunity and guidance. He did well enough against England and should have been persevered with.
Finau has been really dissapointing he goes missing at test level and has been passive.
He hasn’t shown anything to warrant selection.
No he should not have been persevered with.As for Blackadder when did I compare him to PsDt, Kaino or Juan Smith you just moved the goalposts to protect your post.
I said the BS being talked about Blackadder is tiresome and he has played well in the last couple of games also the spotlight should turn on some other players instead.
Nothing about him being world class. -
1 Williams
2 Taylor
3 Lomax
4 Barrett
5 Vaai
6 Sititi
7 Cane
8 Savea
9 Ratima
10 McKenzie
11 Telea
12 Barrett
13 Ioane
14 Reece
15 Jordan
16 Aumua
17 Ofa
18 Newell
19 Darry
20 Jacobsen
21 TJP
22 Barrett
23 ALB -
@chchfanatic said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
1 Williams
2 Taylor
3 Lomax
4 Barrett
5 Vaai
6 Sititi
7 Cane
8 Savea
9 Ratima
10 McKenzie
11 Telea
12 Barrett
13 Ioane
14 Reece
15 Jordan
16 Aumua
17 Ofa
18 Newell
19 Darry
20 Jacobsen
21 TJP
22 Barrett
23 ALBwhere dalton
-
@brodean said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
Yes I've already said he had a good workrate.
PsDT, Kaino and Juan Smith all had good workrates but they hit hard and thats the difference. These are the last three blindsides to win World Cups. Do you honestly believe that Blackadder has the upside of these players?
He's never going to be a world class blindside. There are players in NZ with the potential to be that. Finau certainly has the athletic ability he just needs some consistent opportunity and guidance. He did well enough against England and should have been persevered with.
So he's not as good as 3 of the best ever so shouldn't play.
If that's your logic, how are we going to even field a team? -
@Landers92 said in Springboks vs All Blacks 2:
Just been given the backline for this weekend below. Again, this contact hasn’t led me astray before so very reliable. Very very surprised by some choices and the amount of changes which makes you question the accuracy but fuck it, hasn’t been wrong yet so yeah sharing with the fern. Caleb Clarke is out injured.
- Ratima
- Dmac
- Telea
- J.Barrett
- Ioane/ALB(this isn’t yet decided)
- Reece
- Jordan
Bench
21. Perenara
22. B.Barrett
23. Couldn’t quite hear the name or whatever was said there unfortunately, I’m guessing whoever isn’t selected at 13 so either Ioane or ALB.I take it Clarke is injured? Some real improvements (Ratima) , but also telea of no impact? And Jordan is such a risk at full back, he hasn't shown the brains for it
