AS v TJP
-
This post is deleted!
-
-
no that's me just cocking up when trying to post
-
@Wreck-Diver The edit function is your friend. You can change the topic title and first post of a thread that you started.
-
@Stargazer yeah tried that and it didn't work. I also seem to have to always login twice for some reason
-
Well if we are allowed to actually comment on the implied content rather than the technology, are you saying TKB is playing better than AS? I'm not so convinced on that.
AS is still an ok halfback and doing some great things, just not as often (and I have often thought his kicking from the scrum could be dodgy so no surprises there). -
@nostrildamus said in I think Aaron Smith should just pack for home and look forward to next season. TJ and TKB for half back this weekend.:
Well if we are allowed to actually comment on the implied content rather than the technology, are you saying TKB is playing better than AS? I'm not so convinced on that.
AS is still an ok halfback and doing some great things, just not as often (and I have often thought his kicking from the scrum could be dodgy so no surprises there).I just don't think his head or form is right at the moment. TJ should start against France. Smith cost us field position directly after the first try with a crap pass to no one, got sin binned then. Straight after half time he hands the ball directly back to Ireland after the kick off which put us on the back foot and in my eyes set the tone for the half. He kicked poorly as well. Just think TKB coming off the bench is better than the way Smith is playing at the moment.
-
@Crucial said in I think Aaron Smith should just pack for home and look forward to next season. TJ and TKB for half back this weekend.:
Is that a new feature of the board? Put the post in the title and leave the post blank?
Tried to fix. On phone and have had a red wine or two ... may not be successful ... fingers xed
-
Can we read @Wreck-Diver 's initial post?
-
-
@nostrildamus said in AS v TJP:
Well if we are allowed to actually comment on the implied content rather than the technology, are you saying TKB is playing better than AS? I'm not so convinced on that.
AS is still an ok halfback and doing some great things, just not as often (and I have often thought his kicking from the scrum could be dodgy so no surprises there).Wait what? An ok halfback? Seriously? He's a great halfback with some form issues.
TJP is doing good things, but even when Smith is having an average game it's noticeable how much better smith's passing is.
TJPs best moments are on defense and in broken play. That said I would probably give him the start this week. But I don't think he's our best halfback just yet.
-
@mariner4life I agree he is our best half back but just not at the moment. I would say to him forget this game come back next year in top form.
-
My 2c.
AS is probably the best halfback I have ever seen. And I was a Sid Going devotee in 70s North Auckland and have serious man love for Dave Loveridge (my first ever Test was 2nd v Lions at Athtletic Park '83 ... second half into the gale OWNED by the Naki pig farmer).
But his head ain't right.
Give him a rest. Pray that Christmas gives him rest one way or another. Let him re-find his mojo come March.
In the meantime start TJP and give TKB time off the bench.
-
-
-
