All time kiwi league team
-
Was thinking about league greats.
Thought we could spit ball some players and refine to a 13 or 17
1 Kemble, RTS,
2 Dane Ohara, Sean Hoppe , Vatuvei
3 James Leulawue (sp) Ruben Wiki, McCracken, Blackmore, Dean Bell
4 Kev Iro, Fred Ah Kuoi
5 help...
6 Olsen Filapaina, Benji, Gene Ngamu
7 Clayton Friend, Gary Freeman, Stacey, Johnson
8 Kev Tamati, Waewera Hargreves, Brent Todd, Quentin Pongia
9 Howie Tamati, Isaac Luke,
10 John Lomax,
11 help
12 Mark Graham
13 Tawera NikauAs you can see I have retrograde amnesia.
Would love to be reminded of the names I've missed -
Vatuvei played a lot more at 5 than 2.
SBW at 11?
-
@Siam the other Iro, the Paul's, Lauitiiti...
-
Ridge
-
-
@Siam said in All time kiwi league team:
Was thinking about league greats.
Thought we could spit ball some players and refine to a 13 or 17
1 Kemble, RTS,
2 Dane Ohara, Sean Hoppe , Vatuvei
3 James Leulawue (sp) Ruben Wiki, McCracken, Blackmore, Dean Bell
4 Kev Iro, Fred Ah Kuoi
5 help...
6 Olsen Filapaina, Benji, Gene Ngamu
7 Clayton Friend, Gary Freeman, Stacey, Johnson
8 Kev Tamati, Waewera Hargreves, Brent Todd, Quentin Pongia
9 Howie Tamati, Isaac Luke,
10 John Lomax,
11 help
12 Mark Graham
13 Tawera NikauAs you can see I have retrograde amnesia.
Would love to be reminded of the names I've missed11 Kurt Sorensen ?
-
@booboo Dane was handy too
Ridge
Halligan -
Reuben Wiki could play 11. Or anywhere in the forward pack
-
Taumalolo and Bromwich (definitely over JWH) are surely in the frame of the modern players. I know the rule is to hate on Blair now but he had a long Kiwi career back when he was good. Roy Asotasi another prop option.
Hugh McGahan and Jeremy Smith for lock. Mannering and Kearney (the player) for the second row.
To put the best team on the field Bell or Iro could go to wing I guess.
Foran as a 6 option - ahead of Ngamu I reckon on the rankings.
Richie Barnett for the wing.
I wonder if there are any oldies on here that can name the 50s and 60s big names?
-
My all-time Kiwis squad would probably be:
1 Matthew Ridge 2. Roger Tuivasa-Sheck 3. Dean Bell 4. Nigel Vagana 5. Manu Vatuvei 6. Gary Freeman 7. Stacey Jones 8. Quentin Pongia 9. Jock Butterfield 10. Maunga Emery 11. Sonny Bill Williams 12. Mark Graham 13. Simon Mannering
Bench: 14. Lance Hohaia 15. Kevin Tamati 16. Rueben Wiki 17. Ali Lauiti'iti -
@Sneakdefreak said in All time kiwi league team:
My all-time Kiwis squad would probably be:
1 Matthew Ridge 2. Roger Tuivasa-Sheck 3. Dean Bell 4. Nigel Vagana 5. Manu Vatuvei 6. Gary Freeman 7. Stacey Jones 8. Quentin Pongia 9. Jock Butterfield 10. Maunga Emery 11. Sonny Bill Williams 12. Mark Graham 13. Simon Mannering
Bench: 14. Lance Hohaia 15. Kevin Tamati 16. Rueben Wiki 17. Ali Lauiti'itiMine would smash yours - when I come up with it (I'll only pick players I've seen play Koro Sneak
). -
@Nepia Maunga Emery was Stacey Jones' grandfather. Him, Jock Butterfield (who I think was nick-named "The Sleepy Fox") and Sam Edwards were the toughest son-of-a-bitch front row in Kiwis league history. Jock has played the most matches for the Kiwis (I think).
-
@Sneakdefreak said in All time kiwi league team:
@Nepia Maunga Emery was Stacey Jones' grandfather. Him, Jock Butterfield (who I think was nick-named "The Sleepy Fox") and Sam Edwards were the toughest son-of-a-bitch front row in Kiwis league history. Jock has played the most matches for the Kiwis (I think).
I know who they are, but obviously never saw them play. If it was based on any era then Nepia, Bert Cooke and Karl Ifwersen would make my team. Two former Magpies and all three ABs and if you read about Ifwersen he was supposedly a god on the field.
-
We have had some great players , I go back a bit more than most here I imagine ,
I grew up down at carlaw park ,
here are a couple of guns I saw play as a kid ,
Roger Bailey , started as a centre , finished at 6 ,
he was our Wally Lewis , just had that ability to pull off the crucial play to win a game ,
Another that came after him , Dennis Williams , also a centre that finished as a 6 ,
Picked for the kiwis at 17 years old , scored with his first touch of the ball stepping through pommy tacklers , was that kind of magic player ,
-
@Nepia that's what I was after thanks. I cringed with memory loss typing Gene friggin Ngamu!
-
Another couple that would be hard to leave out would be the Sorenson brothers , Dane front row , kurt second row
Both were considered the best in the world in their positions at the time ,
they were the first players playing overseas to be selected for the kiwis , before that if you went overseas , ( not too many did ) you said goodbye to the kiwi jersey ,
I tend to think the kiwi jersey meant more a lot back then , all our best players were playing at home, mostly for auckland clubs , ( gee that was a great comp back then, big crowds down at carlaw park every sunday for game of the round ) , and the pinnacle for them was kiwi selection
-
Do we think that Mark Graham was the best? A pine tree type. Always grew up thinking that. Maybe Stacey surpassed?
-
Graeme West from the old Wigan days
-
Kevin Tamati gets an honourable mention
For giving Greg Dowling a TASTE OF KIWI!!!!
-
@Siam said in All time kiwi league team:
Do we think that Mark Graham was the best? A pine tree type. Always grew up thinking that. Maybe Stacey surpassed?
Mark graham was an absolute gun
-
heres my team with a bit of open bias to some heroes from my childhood , but could easily pick others , way too many close calls
- RTS 2 . Dane O Hara 3. Dennis Williams 4, Nigel Vagana 5. Philip Orchard 6 , Roger Bailey 7 . Stacey Jones 8 . Dane Sorenson 9 . Tom Conroy 10. Mark Broadhurst 11, Kurt Sorenson 12 SBW 13 Mark Graham
14 . Clayton friend 15 , Kevin Tamiti 16 . Roy Asotasi 17 Ali Lauititi
-
I'm not a big league fan, no really, but a team of my favorites is (showing my age):
- Gary Kemble
- Tony Iro
- James Leuluai
- Fred Ah Kuoi
- Dane O'Hara
- Gary Freeman
- Stacy Jones
- Dane Sorensen
- Duane Mann
- Mark Broadhurst
- Kurt Sorensen
- Mark Graham
- Hugh McGahan
Don't ask me about a bench... Kevin Iro somewhere there.
-
@booboo we grew up on the same league I think boo.
Duane Mann, thank you. I knew there was another gun hooker -
My team of only players I've seen play:
- Mathew Ridge
- Sean Hoppe
- James Leuluai
- Dean Bell (How is he not getting selected in more teams?
) - Kevin Iro
- Benji Marshall/Olsen Filipaina* (I actually can't pick between these two. I'm not a fan of Freeman at 6.)
- Stacey Jones
- Jesse Bromwich
- Isaac Luke
- Kevin Tamati
- SBW
- Mark Graham
- Hugh McGahan
Bench: 14. Henry Paul, 15. Reuben Wiki, 16. Quentin Pongia, 17. Kurt Sorensen.
-
@kiwiinmelb said in All time kiwi league team:
I grew up down at carlaw park...
Another that came after him , Dennis Williams , also a centre that finished as a 6 ,
Picked for the kiwis at 17 years old , scored with his first touch of the ball stepping through pommy tacklers , was that kind of magic player ,
Thank you. My first thought was Dennis Williams. Maybe ‘cos he was my fave League player, and then Olsen Filipaina.
And crikey, look at the condition of those paddocks back in the Seventies!!
-
@kiwiinmelb said in All time kiwi league team:
@Siam said in All time kiwi league team:
Do we think that Mark Graham was the best? A pine tree type. Always grew up thinking that. Maybe Stacey surpassed?
Mark graham was an absolute gun
On a kiwis tour in the UK he broke his ankle, carried on playing till halftime. Then actually took the field at the start of the 2nd half before coming off.
Guy was the forerunner to Richie McCaw for hardness and putting his team ahead of himself. -
Dally Messenger - just to piss the Ockers off
-
No love for Clinton Toopi ?
-
Craig Innes? I know the Aussies rated him highly.
-
Brendon Tuuta, just for the Chatham Island shoutout.
-
@Virgil said in All time kiwi league team:
@kiwiinmelb said in All time kiwi league team:
@Siam said in All time kiwi league team:
Do we think that Mark Graham was the best? A pine tree type. Always grew up thinking that. Maybe Stacey surpassed?
Mark graham was an absolute gun
On a kiwis tour in the UK he broke his ankle, carried on playing till halftime. Then actually took the field at the start of the 2nd half before coming off.
Guy was the forerunner to Richie McCaw for hardness and putting his team ahead of himself.I remember watching him break into first grade at Oatahuhu as a tall skinny back row forward , the Oatahuhu back row was international quality with himself , Owen Wright and Gary Prohm .
The Oatahuhu coach was Lowe , when Lowe took up his first overseas coaching job at Brisbane , he took Graham with him , in his first game a fight broke out , some player came at Graham shaping up , so graham hit him and knocked him out , being a young kiwi bloke he didnt know alot about reputations in Aus . He knocked out Wally Lewis .
-
@Salacious-Crumb said in All time kiwi league team:
@kiwiinmelb said in All time kiwi league team:
I grew up down at carlaw park...
Another that came after him , Dennis Williams , also a centre that finished as a 6 ,
Picked for the kiwis at 17 years old , scored with his first touch of the ball stepping through pommy tacklers , was that kind of magic player ,
Thank you. My first thought was Dennis Williams. Maybe ‘cos he was my fave League player, and then Olsen Filipaina.
And crikey, look at the condition of those paddocks back in the Seventies!!
I heard some time back Dennis Williams was not going so well ,
had a car accident and lost his memory ,Was fine with the day to day stuff , but couldnt remember the past ,
How tragic , imagine being a gun like that in your day , and you cant remember any of it .
-
@MN5 said in All time kiwi league team:
No love for Clinton Toopi ?
Not when there are 5-6 that are better. Toopi was a bit error prone.
There’s no doubting that the Warriors era of Toopi, Fa’afili, Meli, Lauitiiti was damn good to watch.
-
@Smudge said in All time kiwi league team:
Brendon Tuuta, just for the Chatham Island shoutout.
That fella knew how to throw a punch!
-
@ACT-Crusader said in All time kiwi league team:
@Smudge said in All time kiwi league team:
Brendon Tuuta, just for the Chatham Island shoutout.
That fella knew how to throw a punch!
I remember him being a total madman
-
@ACT-Crusader said in All time kiwi league team:
@MN5 said in All time kiwi league team:
No love for Clinton Toopi ?
Not when there are 5-6 that are better. Toopi was a bit error prone.
There’s no doubting that the Warriors era of Toopi, Fa’afili, Meli, Lauitiiti was damn good to watch.
Fuck yeah. John Carlaw was a great "glue" man around them too. They captured the whole countries imagination back then, could things be any more different now though ?
-
@MN5 who?
-
@Bones said in All time kiwi league team:
@MN5 who?
Read this is and try not to appear so naive next time.
-
@MN5 said in All time kiwi league team:
@Bones said in All time kiwi league team:
@MN5 who?
Read this is and try not to appear so naive next time.
Looks like he stuck around. I must have missed his handful of games.
-
@Bones said in All time kiwi league team:
@MN5 said in All time kiwi league team:
@Bones said in All time kiwi league team:
@MN5 who?
Read this is and try not to appear so naive next time.
Looks like he stuck around. I must have missed his handful of games.
Yeah about two seasons worth which ironically was when I watched the Warriors the most.
John Carlaw - Wikipedia