France v Australia
-
@cgrant said in France v Australia:
A few blunders cost the Wallabies dearly (Foley's pass to nobody for the French first try, Valetini's left foot kick, Hodge's misfiring kick off to name a few, plus the missed tackles on Penaud). But I reckon they will be a force next for the RWC if they can have Beale, Kerevi, Koroibete, Alaalatoa, Sio, Philipp, Rodda, Bell and Leota who were not there today.
Cooper especially.
-
@cgrant said in France v Australia:
A few blunders cost the Wallabies dearly (Foley's pass to nobody for the French first try, Valetini's left foot kick, Hodge's misfiring kick off to name a few, plus the missed tackles on Penaud).
Valetini had a poor game - the ruck just before halftime created the pressure for White and then Foley to gift France a try. The kick. The lack of carries and penetration. He was caught flat footed a few times but just seemed to be absent in the top two inches.
Frost also dropped a kick off cold, which I notice he did against Scotland. Otherwise, for a 23yo kid with those physical stats, he's a keeper. Our locking stocks will be good for next year, pending injury.
We lost four lineouts by my count (picked off twice and 2 not straight) which also didn't help.
But I reckon they will be a force next for the RWC if they can have Beale, Kerevi, Koroibete, Alaalatoa, Sio, Philipp, Rodda, Bell and Leota who were not there today.
I don't know about "a force" but we'll hopefully be staunch enough to get out of our group. Semifinals would be over achieving given our inconsistency. The way we're travelling right now there are no guarantees that will improve things
Definitely adding Kerevi and Koroibete makes us more of a threat. Ditch Wright for the latter - for every good thing he does, there is something unutterably stupid in his game.
Most of a forward pack of good talent missing in what you've named, tho the guys who are there right now are doing a good job. We put the French scrum under serious pressure, and they're no mugs.
The asterisk on this game: France's first time out this season. They'll be much better next week so this was our chance. Not to be - c'est la vie
-
@KiwiMurph said in France v Australia:
That try concede on halftime is a coach killer.
Yeah, but I look at the sliding doors and think "whatever".
It is just as likely we lose by a point as France go on a second half rampage if they head to the sheds 13-12 down
-
@KiwiMurph still think they are dark horse at next years 2023 RWC , if they can get their best 23 assembled they will be a threat
Samu Kerevi and Marika Koroibete back in starting XV makes them an even more dangerous beast -
-
@ACT-Crusader and so many times we will find a way to fuck up that sort of play. Wright doesn't pass, or passes too early/late, being the first two options I can think of.
-
@KiwiMurph said in France v Australia:
With Frost, Valetini, Tupou, Holloway and Skelton the Wallabies pack has plenty of size and with Laurie Fisher putting together a good maul defence it puts the Wallabies right in the contest.
Back to this - here is a potential Wallabies team with another year of pro footy under its belt:
1 Bell
2 Porecki
3 Alaalatoa (c)
4 Frost
5 Philip
6 Holloway
7 Hooper
8 Valetini
9 White
10 Cooper
11 Koroibete
12 Kerevi
13 Ikitau
14 Kellaway
15 Campbell (yes I think he's good enough)16 Fainga'a / Lonergan / Pollard
17 Slipper / Sio
18 Tupou
19 Skelton / Neville
20 Samu
21 Gordon / McDermott
22 Lolesio / Donaldson / Edmed
23 Nawaqanitawase / Hodge / a host of othersSo we're mostly there in terms of forming up a squad IMHO. And playing at potential could be a very good side, with a few of those disciplinary edges sanded off.
-
So much for an Aussie team ferners think NZ should thrash every time. But for a couple of bits of poor execution from Jock Campbell they could have beaten France. That last ruck cleanout was abysmal and gifted it to Danty.
Just shows how close the top teams are these days.
Penaud is a classy runner but should have been cleaned up before that try. -
@Steven-Harris said in France v Australia:
@KiwiMurph still think they are dark horse at next years 2023 RWC , if they can get their best 23 assembled they will be a threat
Samu Kerevi and Marika Koroibete back in starting XV makes them an even more dangerous beastYep very dangerous if they can put their best team (or close to it) on the park.
-
@Derpus said in France v Australia:
@NTA id like to see BPA brought back into the team. His performances in his last year were far better than Faingaa and Porecki.
I'm not sure Fainga'a deserves his spot based on his throwing and discipline - those fucking stupid cannonball tackles! Laurie Fisher was on twitter after one blatant example saying it wasn't illegal the one time he got away with it, then the next game was horribly silent when he got penalised.
Hopefully someone like Pollard gets more time in Super Rugby and can take the bench spot.
I always thought BPA was good but needed to work on his fitness. Not sure his discipline was anything special either, but maybe playing for the Reds colours my judgement on that
-
That 90m try by the wallabies was as good as any try you'll ever see. Fucking outstanding rugby
-
that French try right on halftime, the French guy at the ruck shoulda bee done for going over and sealing it off.
-
@Stargazer said in France v Australia:
Longer highlights clip (referee channel, without commentary):
I'm a big fan of no commentary footage and I wish it was an option for all games regardless of the telecaster.
-
@Frye said in France v Australia:
@cgrant said in France v Australia:
A few blunders cost the Wallabies dearly (Foley's pass to nobody for the French first try, Valetini's left foot kick, Hodge's misfiring kick off to name a few, plus the missed tackles on Penaud). But I reckon they will be a force next for the RWC if they can have Beale, Kerevi, Koroibete, Alaalatoa, Sio, Philipp, Rodda, Bell and Leota who were not there today.
Cooper especially.
I did not dare to add him to my list since he is unpredictable ...