Canterbury vs Wellington
-
@kiwimurph said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@sammyc Why didnt they just play it as a curtain raiser?
shouldnt that be a double header?
-
@sammyc said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
I guess it's so they school pupils can all go without having to pay for a ticket
There's ways around that. Auckland had the schools game as the curtain raiser last week, it was free entry as long as you arrived before half time
The stadium won't be full for an NPC match and the ground makes money on the food etc
Maybe the field can't handle two games in a row?
-
When's the Canterbury team released?
-
@sammyc said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@canes4life said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
Canterbury will be hell-bent on making amends for their sluggish start against Ta$man last week and will also be looking for some revenge from last years walloping at the Cake Tin.
I see this as a 50-50 game, could go either way. As per usual with Canterbury vs Wellington fixtures, Canterbury look to have a stronger forward back and Wellington look to have a typically potent backline.
I just hope for our sake that Aumua returns to the starting side as O'Reilly doesn't look upto it.
Reuben Thorne will have his skates on. He is coaching Christs College in the UC Championship final which will finish at 2pm before getting on his bike for a 2.05pm kickoff at AMI. If College manages an upset against Boys High Reuben will have to miss the celebrations.
Bloody stupid they couldn't reschedule the schools final till Sunday to avoid this clash. I know a bunch of people that aren't going to watch Canterbury because they are going to the schools game.
I think Wellington will win, very disappointed with the squad Maddock has chosen and we looked directionless last weekend.
Changes you'd make to the squad??
-
@canes4life said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
When's the Canterbury team released?
Still not on the CRFU site and I haven't had my team update email either. Don't know why they're farting around.
I think the forward pack last week was the best we could put out. If there's some prop rotation this week that's no biggie as we have depth there.
I wonder if Mo'unga has been released? Would make some sense all round. He'd be a big 'in' and aside from that I'd shake up the midfield and back three and bring Bridge back in, move Ennor into midfield and the backline would look a lot stronger like this:
9 Drummond
10 Cameron / Mo'unga
12 Burleigh / Beard
13 Ennor
11 Punivai
14 McKay
15 Bridge -
@shark said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
I wonder if Mo'unga has been released? Would make some sense all round.
Until DMac or Beaudie go down in the warm up to the Bledisloe.....
Makes more sense to release Mo'unga to play next weekend when there isn't a test.
-
@kiwimurph said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@shark said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
I wonder if Mo'unga has been released? Would make some sense all round.
Until DMac or Beaudie go down in the warm up to the Bledisloe.....
Makes more sense to release Mo'unga to play next weekend when there isn't a test.
Hence I've bracketed him
-
-
George Bridge, Josh McKay, Braydon Ennor, Sam Beard, Caleb Makene, Brett Cameron, Mitchell Drummond (cc), Whetu Douglas (cc), Tom Christie, Reed Prinsep, Mitchell Dunshea, Luke Romano, Sef Fa'agase, Nathan Vella, Alex Hodgman
Reserves: Greg Pleasants-Tate, Daniel Lienert-Brown, Chris King, Hamish Dalzell, Tom Sanders, Connor Collins, James Hawkey, Ngane Punivai
-
@tim said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@sammyc It was weird how excited people were for a mediocre plodder like Phil Burleigh. Surprised he could make that squad.
I wasn't excited as such but given the cattle lost from the midfield over the last couple of years (ie our last two championship combinations in Goodhue & Barrett, Bateman & Thompson) it was pleasing to have a decent veteran available, and I'd been lead to believe his club from was good. Additionally Inga Finau seems to have dropped off the radar.
Not sure how bad Burleighs' injury is but you might be in luck.
-
@shark said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@sammyc said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@canes4life said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
Canterbury will be hell-bent on making amends for their sluggish start against Ta$man last week and will also be looking for some revenge from last years walloping at the Cake Tin.
I see this as a 50-50 game, could go either way. As per usual with Canterbury vs Wellington fixtures, Canterbury look to have a stronger forward back and Wellington look to have a typically potent backline.
I just hope for our sake that Aumua returns to the starting side as O'Reilly doesn't look upto it.
Reuben Thorne will have his skates on. He is coaching Christs College in the UC Championship final which will finish at 2pm before getting on his bike for a 2.05pm kickoff at AMI. If College manages an upset against Boys High Reuben will have to miss the celebrations.
Bloody stupid they couldn't reschedule the schools final till Sunday to avoid this clash. I know a bunch of people that aren't going to watch Canterbury because they are going to the schools game.
I think Wellington will win, very disappointed with the squad Maddock has chosen and we looked directionless last weekend.
Changes you'd make to the squad??
Burleigh was a terrible signing at the expense of Ray Nu'u who moved down to Southland and is a very special player.
Chris King another I wouldn't have signed. Plenty of young talent in that position.
I've dont rate Brett Cameron, he stands far too deep. And Makene is an average at best winger.
I also think Punavai should be at 13 instead of Sam Beard
-
@shark said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@tim said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@sammyc It was weird how excited people were for a mediocre plodder like Phil Burleigh. Surprised he could make that squad.
I wasn't excited as such but given the cattle lost from the midfield over the last couple of years (ie our last two championship combinations in Goodhue & Barrett, Bateman & Thompson) it was pleasing to have a decent veteran available, and I'd been lead to believe his club from was good. Additionally Inga Finau seems to have dropped off the radar.
Not sure how bad Burleighs' injury is but you might be in luck.
Burleigh is a journeyman, if we are going to talk club form then he doesn't come close to Nu'u
-
@sammyc said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@shark said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@sammyc said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@canes4life said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
Canterbury will be hell-bent on making amends for their sluggish start against Ta$man last week and will also be looking for some revenge from last years walloping at the Cake Tin.
I see this as a 50-50 game, could go either way. As per usual with Canterbury vs Wellington fixtures, Canterbury look to have a stronger forward back and Wellington look to have a typically potent backline.
I just hope for our sake that Aumua returns to the starting side as O'Reilly doesn't look upto it.
Reuben Thorne will have his skates on. He is coaching Christs College in the UC Championship final which will finish at 2pm before getting on his bike for a 2.05pm kickoff at AMI. If College manages an upset against Boys High Reuben will have to miss the celebrations.
Bloody stupid they couldn't reschedule the schools final till Sunday to avoid this clash. I know a bunch of people that aren't going to watch Canterbury because they are going to the schools game.
I think Wellington will win, very disappointed with the squad Maddock has chosen and we looked directionless last weekend.
Changes you'd make to the squad??
Burleigh was a terrible signing at the expense of Ray Nu'u who moved down to Southland and is a very special player.
Chris King another I wouldn't have signed. Plenty of young talent in that position.
I've dont rate Brett Cameron, he stands far too deep. And Makene is an average at best winger.
I also think Punavai should be at 13 instead of Sam Beard
I guess they wanted some old heads in the squad, but yeah - probably better off developing some younger players than dragging some old guys in for one last hurrah.
On Mo'unga - he's a huge loss to Canterbury this year - alongside Whitelock, Bird, Thompson and Bateman.
Rugby NZ needs to look at "eligibility" of ABs to participate in play-off matches. I reckon they need to have played a few round robin games to be eligible - otherwise Steve Hansen potentially gets too much say in who wins the competition.
Mo'unga is one who could be released and almost win the competition single handed.
-
Trent Renata, Ben Lam, Matt Proctor (c), Thomas Umaga-Jensen, Wes Goosen, Jackson Garden-Bachop, Sheridan Rangihuna, Thomas Waldrom, Du'Plessis Kirifi, Vaea Fifita, Isaia Walker-Leawere, James Blackwell, Jeff To'omaga-Allen, James O'Reilly, Tolu Fahamokioa.
Reserves: Asafo Aumua, Kaliopasi Uluiakepa, Joel Hintz, Will Mangos, Mateaki Kafatolu, Kemara Hauiti-Parapara, Billy Proctor, Malo Tuitama
Joel Hintz must be one of the smallest NPC props ever so thankfully JTA is available. Hopefully Wellington have another slightly bigger TH with Fidow out for the year it seems.
Isaia Walker-Leawere was quiet last week. But Du'Plessis Kirifi had a good game. Unsure if he is big enough for super rugby but he looks promising at this level. O'Reilly may develop into a good hooker but his lineout throwing needs work
-
@sammyc said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@shark said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@sammyc said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
@canes4life said in Canterbury vs Wellington:
Canterbury will be hell-bent on making amends for their sluggish start against Ta$man last week and will also be looking for some revenge from last years walloping at the Cake Tin.
I see this as a 50-50 game, could go either way. As per usual with Canterbury vs Wellington fixtures, Canterbury look to have a stronger forward back and Wellington look to have a typically potent backline.
I just hope for our sake that Aumua returns to the starting side as O'Reilly doesn't look upto it.
Reuben Thorne will have his skates on. He is coaching Christs College in the UC Championship final which will finish at 2pm before getting on his bike for a 2.05pm kickoff at AMI. If College manages an upset against Boys High Reuben will have to miss the celebrations.
Bloody stupid they couldn't reschedule the schools final till Sunday to avoid this clash. I know a bunch of people that aren't going to watch Canterbury because they are going to the schools game.
I think Wellington will win, very disappointed with the squad Maddock has chosen and we looked directionless last weekend.
Changes you'd make to the squad??
Burleigh was a terrible signing at the expense of Ray Nu'u who moved down to Southland and is a very special player.
Chris King another I wouldn't have signed. Plenty of young talent in that position.
I've dont rate Brett Cameron, he stands far too deep. And Makene is an average at best winger.
I also think Punavai should be at 13 instead of Sam Beard
Burleigh is from Chch and was playing club footy so was he a 'signing' they were compelled to pick or purely selected ahead of Nu'u? Same as Cam McIntyre last year.
King is one of six props. He says himself he'd happily flag it. Yet he acquitted himself well in Super Rugby. The other five are relatively young.
I think you have two examples there of veterans picked a) on merit and b) for their experience.
I think you're a little harsh on Cameron but I wouldn't mind seeing McKay tried at 10.
Makene is a guy who maybe just needs to settle in one position but can't at any level. I suspect his best position is 12 but we shall see.
-
A gentle reminder that this game has a 2:05pm kick off -
-
@sammyc ray nu’u is still young and raw. Coming back from a serious broken leg too. Burleigh is there for a year to fill a gap. Rameka Poihipi would’ve been the 12 but obviously injury curtailed that. Next year guys like nu’u , Dallas McLeod , punivai etc will have developed more. Sam beard is the plodder. Burleigh is class , just on ageing legs. Name a better 10 in Canterbury at the moment. I like Fergus Burke but he’s only 18/19. There’s some great kids coming through at the moment.
-
@winger the good thing about Hintz is he is a champion power lifter so can probably hold his own at scrum time even though he is pint size. I would rather that than have a big lump that gets blown off the ball.
I like our chances today, especially with Matt Proctor back in the side. We have the luxury of rotating backs all the way through the comp with the depth we have developed over the last couple of seasons. Our problem will be if we start getting injuries in our tight five, there aren't too many good props / locks running around club rugby atm, most of our depth in that area have gone to other provinces.
-
Ive changed my mind in Bridge ever being an AB. At least until he loses the fucking alice band
-
I don't get to watch much of it, but i do enjoy the loose fluid nature of NPC rugby
