Canadian Politics
-
@rotated said in Canadian Politics:
The other issue to consider is much like NZ, part of Canada's identity is being "not USA". Given the distribution of most power to the provinces immigration is the only vexing issue currently and it's going to be very tricky for a conservative to run hard against Trudeau on that issue without veering uncomfortably far into Trump territory for the Canadian public.
Say what you like about Trudeau but he does have a statsmanlike pedigree/appearance that is appealing to those that keep only a cursory eye on proceedings. I think Canada would prefer a seemingly well meaning empty suit than an abrasive type.
Good post . Harper was around for quite a while though wasn’t he?
-
@rotated said in Canadian Politics:
The other issue to consider is much like NZ, part of Canada's identity is being "not USA". Given the distribution of most power to the provinces immigration is the only vexing issue currently and it's going to be very tricky for a conservative to run hard against Trudeau on that issue without veering uncomfortably far into Trump territory for the Canadian public.
Say what you like about Trudeau but he does have a statsmanlike pedigree/appearance that is appealing to those that keep only a cursory eye on proceedings. I think Canada would prefer a seemingly well meaning empty suit than an abrasive type.
Do you think the Frenchiness of Bernier will count against him? I saw his interview with Rubin and he seems pretty clued up..just hard to listen to.
-
Problem for Trudeau and the boomers is that they remember his father. He was polarizing, half of them hated Pierre, but NONE of the people who hated Justin’s father EVER believed he was a lightweight. The people who hated him knew best how formidible an opponent he was, truly a giant. By contrast the kid is a featherweight, and those boomers — even the ones who voted for him — don’t see him as a chip off the old block or the apple falling far from the tree, they see him as crazy flower-child Margaret’s kid, maybe a little too much reefer hanging out with the Stones at a young age turned his brain to porridge, and they know he’s not a tough brawler with an acid tongue like his dad.
-
@jegga said in Canadian Politics:
Good post . Harper was around for quite a while though wasn’t he?
Yep for sure; I only turned up in Canada for the final few years of his run but he was very much a conservative whose strong suit was his economic credentials not unlike Howard in Australia and was voted out in much the same way; partly fatigue, partly the hot new thing and partly they just got too draconian on a few issues.
@Rembrandt said in Canadian Politics:
Do you think the Frenchiness of Bernier will count against him? I saw his interview with Rubin and he seems pretty clued up..just hard to listen to.
Frenchiness is almost mandatory. Seven of the thirteen post-WWII PMs were from Quebec ridings, with two of those non-QC PMs being mid-term replacements of less than a year. It is an unofficial requirement for all party leaders to speak French - so it is pretty much expected.
Bernier is going to have issues because he on the outside in a three party system and is the hardest on immigration (therefore the easiest to compare smear) and is deadset against supply control in the dairy and poultry industry which leads to big lobby dollars coming in against him.
He would thrive in MMP though.
-
@Salacious-Crumb said in Canadian Politics:
Problem for Trudeau and the boomers is that they remember his father. He was polarizing, half of them hated Pierre, but NONE of the people who hated Justin’s father EVER believed he was a lightweight. The people who hated him knew best how formidible an opponent he was, truly a giant. By contrast the kid is a featherweight, and those boomers — even the ones who voted for him — don’t see him as a chip off the old block or the apple falling far from the tree, they see him as crazy flower-child Margaret’s kid, maybe a little too much reefer hanging out with the Stones at a young age turned his brain to porridge, and they know he’s not a tough brawler with an acid tongue like his dad.
Do you live in Canada Crumb? (not sarcastic genuine question).
My experience among the boomers in Ontario is that he has exceed expectations. It was made widely known during the election before entering politics his highest level of employment was a substitute drama teacher. People knew they were electing on genetics and fatigue alone (and of course... he does have great hair).
Yes he is a disingenuous virtue-signaller (or a bit of a dag if such a term existed in Canada), but given how most power lies with the provinces isn't that half the role (in peacetime, with no major economic crises). I would say that the general consensus is he sticks up for Canada's interest well, they like him taking it to Saudi Arabia, they think plays indignant on the international stage and they like the contrast with Trump.
Depending on immigration formalities I would/will Conservative or Bernier's party but even I would have to admit they absolutely schooled Trump on the NAFTA renegotiation.
-
@rotated said in Canadian Politics:
The other issue to consider is much like NZ, part of Canada's identity is being "not USA". Given the distribution of most power to the provinces immigration is the only vexing issue currently and it's going to be very tricky for a conservative to run hard against Trudeau on that issue without veering uncomfortably far into Trump territory for the Canadian public.
** Say what you like about Trudeau but he does have a statsmanlike pedigree/appearance that is appealing to those that keep only a cursory eye on proceedings.** I think Canada would prefer a seemingly well meaning empty suit than an abrasive type.
Yep, and it's those people who tend to decide elections. It can get ugly when they eventually take a closer look at who they're voting for but that can take an election cycle or two.
-
Such a great photo.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/D0feeqlXQAEX0vZ?format=jpg&name=900x900
-
This is not good news for Canada
Consumption spending grew at the slowest pace in almost four years, housing fell by the most in a decade, business investment dropped sharply for a second straight quarter, and domestic demand posted its largest decline since 2015.
contrast to the 4th quarter of the U.S.
“Consumer spending continued to grow solidly and, most encouragingly, business investment growth recovered sharply after a dip in the third quarter. Despite big external headwinds and financial market volatility in the fourth quarter, U.S. firms are not retrenching sharply on capex.”
This could be an aberration. Need a few more quarters for confirmation.
-
Could be criminal charges. That former Justice Minister who they attempted to prrssure, and then demoted, and who blew the whistle at the parliamentary committee last week has a big pair of onions. Real guts standing up to the PMO.
And strangely enough somewhat tangentially related are the weird spooky connections of Trudeau to the NXIVM sex-cult via the Bronfman heiress, all tied up in the SNC Lavalin deal in Libya. Could be ginned-up Maddow-style connect-the-dots conspiracy theory, but something to keep an eye on.
-
@jegga You can add a second minister to the list now: Treasury Board president Jane Philpott, considered a star minister, said in a resignation letter that it was “untenable” for her to continue in the cabinet because she could not defend the government.
-
@antipodean said in Canadian Politics:
@jegga You can add a second minister to the list now: Treasury Board president Jane Philpott, considered a star minister, said in a resignation letter that it was “untenable” for her to continue in the cabinet because she could not defend the government.
That’s the one I mentioned, massive respect for her and the attorney general for showing so much integrity.
-
@jegga said in Canadian Politics:
Grab your popcorn, the first minister has resigned over this .Effectively says she can’t support Trudeau anymore in her statement. Between this and the Canadian economy flagging it could be the end of the Trudeau government.
Trump must be loving this. Macron & Treudeu both virtue signalling piston wristed gibbons who keep trying to put the boot into him and all the while their governments (and countries) are collapsing around them.
-
@Rembrandt said in Canadian Politics:
@jegga said in Canadian Politics:
Grab your popcorn, the first minister has resigned over this .Effectively says she can’t support Trudeau anymore in her statement. Between this and the Canadian economy flagging it could be the end of the Trudeau government.
Trump must be loving this. Macron & Treudeu both virtue signalling piston wristed gibbons who keep trying to put the boot into him and all the while their governments (and countries) are collapsing around them.
It’s not going to be as funny for us when Ardern is next and she drags us down with her. In the meantime I’m enjoying this.
-
@Rembrandt said in [Canadian Politics]
Trump must be loving this. Macron & Treudeu both virtue signalling piston wristed gibbons who keep trying to put the boot into him and all the while their governments (and countries) are collapsing around them.
Australia has a right wing government that has been happy to placate and fallate the US and has pretty much lost the entire centrist faction of the Coalition in a single term.
Self preservation is simply a function of the Westminster system and thank god for that. Say what you want about the Canadian Libs but at least they have the spine (or foresight) to eject early and play the long game, unlike many of the US republicans which just lined up behind Trump despite massive personal misgivings.
-
@rotated said in Canadian Politics:
@Rembrandt said in [Canadian Politics]
Trump must be loving this. Macron & Treudeu both virtue signalling piston wristed gibbons who keep trying to put the boot into him and all the while their governments (and countries) are collapsing around them.
Australia has a right wing government that has been happy to placate and fallate the US and has pretty much lost the entire centrist faction of the Coalition in a single term.
Self preservation is simply a function of the Westminster system and thank god for that. Say what you want about the Canadian Libs but at least they have the spine (or foresight) to eject early and play the long game, unlike many of the US republicans which just lined up behind Trump despite massive personal misgivings.
Credit where credit is due regarding politicians that act on principle, very rare. I would disagree regarding some of the Republicans, many have been making things very difficult for him as he isn't exactly the establishment Republican type. A number have however seen his big wins and just how popular he has become. Whether they have seen the light or know that the writing is on the wall for them if they don't buck up their ideas, who knows? - Anyway thats probably more for the US politics thread.
I went to a feminist (well more accurately man-hating-victimhood-addicted-radical-feminist) event about 18 months ago, I distinctly remember one of the speakers mentioning Trudeau as like the perfect leader and the whole crowd cheered. That memory is going to keep me smiling if he falls as expected.
-
@rotated said in Canadian Politics:
@Rembrandt said in [Canadian Politics]
Trump must be loving this. Macron & Treudeu both virtue signalling piston wristed gibbons who keep trying to put the boot into him and all the while their governments (and countries) are collapsing around them.
Australia has a right wing government that has been happy to placate and fallate the US and has pretty much lost the entire centrist faction of the Coalition in a single term.
Self preservation is simply a function of the Westminster system and thank god for that. Say what you want about the Canadian Libs but at least they have the spine (or foresight) to eject early and play the long game, unlike many of the US republicans which just lined up behind Trump despite massive personal misgivings.
Yeah nah. Comparing Trudeaus real issues with the baseless accusations against Trump is an amazing false equivalence. Trudeau has been exposed with little effort. Nothing of any substance has been found against Trump despite ab FBI investigation (complete with with dishonest agents), a indepent counsel (appointed based on fraudelent dossier), a biased hostile media and a far left radical political opposition.