Rank your AB RWC coaches
-
@stodders said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
In all seriousness, best to worst)
Lochore (reinvigorated a team that was torn apart by Cavaliers tour)
Henry (his team were down to 4th best flyhalf and NZ hadnāt won RWC for 24 years)
Hansen
Foster (if he wins)
Mains (best team in RWC. Would have won if it wasnāt for Matt Damon, low flying jumbos and Saint Nelson)
Mitchell (got Eddieād)
Wyllie (got Campoād)
Hart (that French game was an aberration, but so in keeping with the shit show from 1998)
Foster (if he doesnāt win)You forgot Suzie and her dodgy tea urn
-
For me it is irrelevant if he wins or loses.
I'd loathe if test rugby has come to this where we sacrifice 3 years of test rugby purely to win the RWC, I love that in rugby every game matters, or used to, we don't have 'friendlies'.
-
@stodders said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
Foster (if he wins) must rank as the best given heās coaching the worst NZ team ever to appear at a World Cup against amazing, generational teams like France, Ireland and SA š
That's a very good shout
-
@stodders said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
Lochore (reinvigorated a team that was torn apart by Cavaliers tour)
Henry (his team were down to 4th best flyhalf and NZ hadnāt won RWC for 24 years)
Hansen
Foster (if he wins)
Mains (best team in RWC. Would have won if it wasnāt for Matt Damon, low flying jumbos and Saint Nelson)
Mitchell (got Eddieād)
Wyllie (got Campoād)
Hart (that French game was an aberration, but so in keeping with the shit show from 1998)
Foster (if he doesnāt win)This looks pretty close to me. Though I'd put Mitchell ahead of Mains.
Arguably, the difference between the 1992 - 1994 Laurie Mains shambles (selection idiocies over the three years, and eventually 2 wins from 6 in 1994) and 1995 Laure Mains was the addition of Brian Lochore into the 1995 RWC mix. So I tend to credit that campaign in Lochore's direction as well.
-
@taniwharugby said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
For me it is irrelevant if he wins or loses.
I'd loathe if test rugby has come to this where we sacrifice 3 years of test rugby purely to win the RWC, I love that in rugby every game matters, or used to, we don't have 'friendlies'.
I agree with this. Even if he wins, Foster has done serious damage to the aura, built by those who came before him
-
At the risk of fueling the Foster side of it, at the moment he's last behind daylight after losing the first pool game, the usual standard of post game delusions, and the point well made by @taniwharugby about the damage done over the last three and half years.
If he wins, I think it will feel like a reverse version of the 2019 CWC Final. A very delighted version of disbelief.
-
@MN5 said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
@Kiwiwomble said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
@MN5 im the same if im honest...but the bias otago fan in me will also probably claim hart relied on a core of a team that Mains brought together...and probably the same with Hansen and Henry
*dont ask me to back that up with any facts...remember where we are
Hart took a punt on Cullen. If he didnāt we would have had to put up with a far inferior fullback in Glen Osborne.
Mains wanted to take Cullen away on the France tour as an extra player but the NZRFU wouldn't let him. So not sure if Hart would have been the only one to do that.
-
@Nepia said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
@MN5 said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
@Kiwiwomble said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
@MN5 im the same if im honest...but the bias otago fan in me will also probably claim hart relied on a core of a team that Mains brought together...and probably the same with Hansen and Henry
*dont ask me to back that up with any facts...remember where we are
Hart took a punt on Cullen. If he didnāt we would have had to put up with a far inferior fullback in Glen Osborne.
Mains wanted to take Cullen away on the France tour as an extra player but the NZRFU wouldn't let him. So not sure if Hart would have been the only one to do that.
The comment was more a dig at Foster and how set in his ways he is.
Also Iām just re reading what I wrote and need to correct myself. Osborne was āinferiorā but not by much. He was a terrific player. If Cullen never existed he would have had a long successful career.
-
@taniwharugby said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
For me it is irrelevant if he wins or loses.
I'd loathe if test rugby has come to this where we sacrifice 3 years of test rugby purely to win the RWC, I love that in rugby every game matters, or used to, we don't have 'friendlies'.
I donāt think thereās been any sacrifice per se. Just that weāve struggled on several fronts.
Plus sometimes the best team of the previous three years (or even the previous year) doesnāt win the cup. Sometimes the draw and things just fall into place for the tourney.
He may go up a place or two if he and the team manage to pull off a miracle.
-
@ACT-Crusader said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
@taniwharugby said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
For me it is irrelevant if he wins or loses.
I'd loathe if test rugby has come to this where we sacrifice 3 years of test rugby purely to win the RWC, I love that in rugby every game matters, or used to, we don't have 'friendlies'.
I donāt think thereās been any sacrifice per se. Just that weāve struggled on several fronts.
Plus sometimes the best team of the previous three years (or even the previous year) doesnāt win the cup. Sometimes the draw and things just fall into place for the tourney.
He may go up a place or two if he and the team manage to pull off a miracle.
I guess it comes down to the value placed on a RWC trophy vs our match record over his entire tenure. I guess if you use Laurie as the example, his near miss in 1995 served to fluff his resume in spite of the poor years prior.
-
@canefan and I agree with both of you. The damage he has done will take quite a while to repair.
His acceptance of mediocrity and poor performances and his mealy mouthed justifications really piss me off.
He has never seemed disturbed at what he has overseen and his interviews and pressers have made the colour beige look real exciting.
Iāve been watching the ABs since the 1970s and have never felt this detached until this turkey came along. -
on a more positive note I liked how Ryan accepted blame for the forwards' performance, accepted Ethan DeG had much still to learn, but also shouldered responsibility.
-
@MN5 said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
Also Iām just re reading what I wrote and need to correct myself. Osborne was āinferiorā but not by much. He was a terrific player. If Cullen never existed he would have had a long successful career.
Thank you, there can be a tendency on TSF to compare fine players to once in a lifetime legends.
-
@canefan revisionism
His poor years included series wins over the Lions and the Boks and very tight losses to the Wallabies.
He had a series loss to the French and some dodgy one-off test results but he rebuilt the team during a period when our options in certain positions were very limited.
He did make some strange decisions and had his favourites but he sorted that out. It also has to be noted that the decision most often quoted was choosing Pene ahead of Zinny but those that say that conveniently forget that Pene was voted player of the year when he kept Zinny on the bench.
All of thgis without the backing of Eddie Tonks or the media who were in the Hart camp and with Hart constantly working to undermine him.
It would be interesting to see how Hart would have gone if he had got the gig in 92 which he would have if he'd not tried to white ant Wyllie.
You can't ignore the results in 96/7 but that was Mains team plus Cullen who Mains would have had if he had been supported. Hart also made some strange calls and when he had to rebuild the team it all fell apart catastrophically.
IMO Hart is on a par with Fozie. Two great years undermined by two poor ones and eight years of systematically working to undermine AB rugby for his own personal interests. Something Fozzie has never done.
He was a mouthy arrogant prick as half-back who thought he was way better than he actually was . Nothing changed. Talk to anyone who worked with him at Fletchers and he is universally despised. He's the anti-Wayne Smith.
Lochore
Henry
Hansen
Mains
Hart
Mitchell
WyllieBased on RWC results
-
@dogmeat said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
@canefan revisionism
His poor years included series wins over the Lions and the Boks and very tight losses to the Wallabies.
He had a series loss to the French and some dodgy one-off test results but he rebuilt the team during a period when our options in certain positions were very limited.
He did make some strange decisions and had his favourites but he sorted that out. It also has to be noted that the decision most often quoted was choosing Pene ahead of Zinny but those that say that conveniently forget that Pene was voted player of the year when he kept Zinny on the bench.
All of thgis without the backing of Eddie Tonks or the media who were in the Hart camp and with Hart constantly working to undermine him.
It would be interesting to see how Hart would have gone if he had got the gig in 92 which he would have if he'd not tried to white ant Wyllie.
You can't ignore the results in 96/7 but that was Mains team plus Cullen who Mains would have had if he had been supported. Hart also made some strange calls and when he had to rebuild the team it all fell apart catastrophically.
IMO Hart is on a par with Fozie. Two great years undermined by two poor ones and eight years of systematically working to undermine AB rugby for his own personal interests. Something Fozzie has never done.
He was a mouthy arrogant prick as half-back who thought he was way better than he actually was . Nothing changed. Talk to anyone who worked with him at Fletchers and he is universally despised. He's the anti-Wayne Smith.
Lochore
Henry
Hansen
Mains
Hart
Mitchell
WyllieBased on RWC results
Thanks for reminding me of a few things mate. I didn't want to sound too harsh about Laurie, he was coach when I was at Otago Uni so obviously attained mythical level status. I remember him struggling to settle on some combinations, and that it all came together in 1995. I still can't believe how we failed to win that game, although having over half the team crook as did not help. And yes I would also give him credit for building the team that Hart profited off
-
Yeah, Mains did a lot of experimenting to get that 1995 team together. Some good luck, some good management but it was a hell of a side by the time of the WC. And while Mehrtens arriving was largely the thing that fixed it, Mains still had to pick him and settle on a team and he did that.
No coach should really get credit for Cullen arriving. An absolute freak who it would have been madness not to pick. At fullback. Not at centre. That would be madness. -
@reprobate said in Rank your AB RWC coaches:
Yeah, Mains did a lot of experimenting to get that 1995 team together. Some good luck, some good management but it was a hell of a side by the time of the WC. And while Mehrtens arriving was largely the thing that fixed it, Mains still had to pick him and settle on a team and he did that.
No coach should really get credit for Cullen arriving. An absolute freak who it would have been madness not to pick. At fullback. Not at centre. That would be madness.The prosecution against John Hart's RWC record rests your honour
-
Hart should have replaced Lochore as the AB team was essentially his Auckland team. Another example of the politics within NZR. The counter to your argument about Tonks is that Meads and Sturgeon were instrumental in Mains getting the position ahead of Hart. It went both ways.
Back to Mains, his biggest failing was that he was a terrible selector. He and Thorburn picked some average Otago and NH players over those dominating in the NPC.
