RWC QF: France v South Africa
-
great effort Booboo. Loving this entirely theoretical rugby law chat.
If you go for a ball without trying to catch it to block a pass and it goes forwards, then I would suggest that could be considered an intentional knock on, as you intended not to catch it and you knocked it on...
-
@booboo said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@Frank said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
I came here for a bit of game analysis and all I can find are nerds talking about law interpretations.
And you repeat yourself.
Well there could be a guest spot here by SBW or Marshall talking about law interpretations...
-
@Bones said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@booboo said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
The difference being the ball bouncing off you rather than playing from possession
Gets murky eh, is chest or shoulder a knock on? Dollars to donuts anytime someone tries to catch a kick/pass and it goes forward off shoulder/chest/thigh it gets called knock on.
Not if you're Joe Marler?
-
@Dodge said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
great effort Booboo. Loving this entirely theoretical rugby law chat.
If you go for a ball without trying to catch it to block a pass and it goes forwards, then I would suggest that could be considered an intentional knock on, as you intended not to catch it and you knocked it on...
@Booboo - Nigel has just confirmed in Whistle Watch what I've said above, go one handed, no attempt to catch, if it goes forward, irrespective of what direction your hand is moving etc, then it would have been penalty for an intentional knock on
-
A better angle Kolbe's charge down, absolute perfect timing, sorry on TikTakTo
-
@booboo said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@Dan54 said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@stodders said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@TeWaio Slippery slope there. There was nothing wrong with the French pass that Etzebeth slapped down. Etzebeth took the risk, not the French passer. He got away with it. I imagine he wouldn't if Wayne Barnes was reffing
I thought he had his hand in front of ball and was trying to reef/knock it backwards, and that was why I thought BOK got it right. I definitely didn't see it as a knock down. But then again I haven't ben back to study it again, as I not sure I would get anything out of it.
Again, knock DOWN is not illegal.
Couldn't agree more mate, I never really thought O'Keefe got call wrong.
I can't believe anyone thinks it is. -
-
@antipodean said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Sure they were better. So what was the final score again Mike?
-
@canefan said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@antipodean said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
Sure they were better. So what was the final score again Mike?
The difference between taking your chances and not.
-
-
-
World Rugby identify FIVE refereeing mistakes from controversial France-South Africa clash
World Rugby have admitted to five mistakes in the Rugby World Cup quarter-final match between France and South Africa following referee Ben O'Keeffe's
-
@pakman said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
World Rugby identify FIVE refereeing mistakes from controversial France-South Africa clash
World Rugby have admitted to five mistakes in the Rugby World Cup quarter-final match between France and South Africa following referee Ben O'Keeffe's
3-2 errors, a card each, nearly balances out?
-
@nostrildamus said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@pakman said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
World Rugby identify FIVE refereeing mistakes from controversial France-South Africa clash
World Rugby have admitted to five mistakes in the Rugby World Cup quarter-final match between France and South Africa following referee Ben O'Keeffe's
3-2 errors, a card each, nearly balances out?
Do they want go back and run the rule over Wayne Barnes' performance in the 2007 France/ABs match?
-
@pakman said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
World Rugby identify FIVE refereeing mistakes from controversial France-South Africa clash
World Rugby have admitted to five mistakes in the Rugby World Cup quarter-final match between France and South Africa following referee Ben O'Keeffe's
Tellingly, there's no actual evidence of WR admitting to mistakes.
-
Perfect timing IMHO
-
@canefan said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@nostrildamus said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
@pakman said in RWC QF: France v South Africa:
World Rugby identify FIVE refereeing mistakes from controversial France-South Africa clash
World Rugby have admitted to five mistakes in the Rugby World Cup quarter-final match between France and South Africa following referee Ben O'Keeffe's
3-2 errors, a card each, nearly balances out?
Do they want go back and run the rule over Wayne Barnes' performance in the 2007 France/ABs match?
I doubt it but would be a popular move by some Kiwis
Was this WR refereeing report a leak or a public release?
