Rugby Freaks
-
Haven't read thread. I nominate the following three players without any prior thought.
- Lomu. Sure he was bigger than everyone else, but he wasn't a lumbering buffoon; he had pace, power and balance.
- Cullen. There's never been a better fullback. Never. Just look at any of his highlight reels on youtube.
- Caucau. For a brief period he looked like he was playing against park footballers.
-
@taniwharugby said in Rugby Freaks:
@dice when he was interested...sometimes he didnt even look like he was trying!
It was Cully's explosive pace that covered up his positional deficiencies on defence allowing him to cover.
You're probably a better judge than me. I only really remember his defense for the Blues, which I found impressive.
-
-
@majorrage I'd go Pierre Spies, that dude was a freakish athlete, although never really fulfilled the potential
-
@taniwharugby said in Rugby Freaks:
@majorrage I'd go Pierre Spies, that dude was a freakish athlete, although never really fulfilled the potential
I remember saying he was going to be a star performer when he came onto the scene in the U21s.
-
Pound for pound freaks
Props
Tom Smith, Scotland and Lions
Brian Williams, Wales -
-
@arhs said in Rugby Freaks:
Cullen Campo J van der Westhuizen Serevi Hugo Porta would be my top 5.
Good call
-
George Smith is as close to a complete rugby player as I've seen as well.
-
@taniwharugby said in Rugby Freaks:
@majorrage I'd go Pierre Spies, that dude was a freakish athlete, although never really fulfilled the potential
He was a freakish athlete, no question, but he was a bit soft at the very top level. Not sure why, had all the attributes.
-
-
Campese was also a freak player.His pace, goose step ability to size up situations was impressive.He could also kick goals and had a big boot on him.He was at another level at wing the first few years of his career, he made our wingers look pedestrian when he first came on to the international scene.
Pity he was such a tosser. -
@chris said in Rugby Freaks:
Campese was also a freak player.His pace, goose step ability to size up situations was impressive.He could also kick goals and had a big boot on him.He was at another level at wing the first few years of his career, he made our wingers look pedestrian when he first came on to the international scene.
Pity he was such a tosser.No need for past tense there. Nothings changed on the few times I've met him.
-
@majorrage said in Rugby Freaks:
@chris said in Rugby Freaks:
Campese was also a freak player.His pace, goose step ability to size up situations was impressive.He could also kick goals and had a big boot on him.He was at another level at wing the first few years of his career, he made our wingers look pedestrian when he first came on to the international scene.
Pity he was such a tosser.No need for past tense there. Nothings changed on the few times I've met him.
Even though I have never met him I am not surprised.
-
@majorrage said in Rugby Freaks:
Skinstad was something else when he first came on the scene.
Andrew Walker probably the most natural runner I’ve seen on a rugby field.
Walker was in a class above, he played on instinct which he had in spades - simply exceptional. He was a beautifully balanced runner, similar to Jason Little, could step and swerve and find his way through openings which simply did not exist! He had splendid natural ability, reminiscent of Mark Ella.
He battled the grog, went on benders and Eddie Jones never stopped caring for him and responding whenever his wife called for help. He did it for Walker's welfare, not to enhance his own Brumbies and Wallabies record. He was finding Andrew work in league, using his vast network, long after he left rugby.
Eddie once left a Wallaby camp at Coffs Harbour to go down south looking for him when he went walkabout. He understood the phenomenon - he grew up with the La Perouse locals, went to Matraville High with the Ellas and Lloyd Walker - and he demonstrated outstanding ability to work with it. He's an easy mark for the big mouths who know not much, Eddie, yet he has a long history of going well beyond the ordinary fellow in his efforts for his fellow man.
-
Lots of great players being touted here, but we're supposed to be talking about freaks.
-
@victor-meldrew said in Rugby Freaks:
@arhs said in Rugby Freaks:
Cullen Campo J van der Westhuizen Serevi Hugo Porta would be my top 5.
Good call
Hugo Porta, certainly, we saw him do some wondrous things with consummate ease in the '87 World Cup - taking a ball at Concord near halfway, on the sideline in front of the stand. He glanced at the advancing defence and nonchalantly dropped the ball over for three points - just couldn't be bothered expending energy unnecessarily. His left winger, RAF Flying Officer Rory Underwood turned to the crowd and gestured, palms up, as if to say "Is there anything this genius cannot do?"
Hugo was appointed Ambassador to South Africa and later became a Minister in the Argentine government.
David Campese was simply the best, talented, quick, creative and focused. He epitomised excellence, and led the way for players to earn good money in Europe before the game turned professional.
He cops criticism from lesser men and I doubt he hears it because he has always been a bit busy being successful. He is not at all friendly.
-
Your Zinzan Brooke was special - splendid, especially capable, a joy to watch. He ran like a centre holding the ball out in front and was a punishing tackler.
-
@catogrande said in Rugby Freaks:
Lots of great players being touted here, but we're supposed to be talking about freaks.
So you will throw your boot at the screen if I mention Tony Woodcock or Greg Somerville ... Anton Oliver?
