2022 TSF Team of the Year
-
Coming soon to a forum near you!
Will follow normal process:
- nominations (by position)
- ridicule
- voting
- more ridicule
There's still two big Tests (out of window) to be played this weekend to round out the year so nominations to open thereafter.
Please have your supporting, and opposing arguments handy. (But if you're going to do the latter provide an alternative!)
-
Hi Team
Nomination threads are ready to rock as soon as @Duluth makes the sub-forum visible.
A quick recaps on the rules as they currently stand:
- Nominee must have played at least one Test Match
- Form in all levels of rugby is admissible as evidence, but please refer 1
- Nominees must be backed with some decent reasoning
- Stupid nominations and suggestions will be mocked pitilessly
- Good ones will be welcomed
- All other rules made up as we go along
The TOTY Committee (i.e., me) is the sole judge of fact and law (even if this phrase is no longer in rugby’s laws).
Will get back to close nominations and set up polls maybe around Christmas, and try and do voting thereafter and for a couple of weeks into the New Year.
-
-
@booboo said in 2022 TSF Team of the Year:
@canefan said in 2022 TSF Team of the Year:
The Black Ferns must be team of the year
We're not the Halbergs.
How many RWCs did everyone else win?
-
@canefan said in 2022 TSF Team of the Year:
@booboo said in 2022 TSF Team of the Year:
@canefan said in 2022 TSF Team of the Year:
The Black Ferns must be team of the year
We're not the Halbergs.
How many RWCs did everyone else win?
I don't disagree but I'm not sure you've grasped the concept of these threads.
-
I also like the NZ women's team for winning the RWC however just so that there are other teams..
Portugal for getting to the next world cup since their only previous appearance in 2007. Not that any locals can buy tickets! lol
Bonus virtual chocolate fish question, they came last in their pool without winning a game in 2007, but scored their most points in a game against which nation?
-
A reminder peeps.
https://www.forum.thesilverfern.com/category/51/team-of-the-yearNominate please and debate at will.
I commend you all for the spirit with which you have embraced the process.
Will close nominations and set up pools next weekend when I've got lazy time.
Will keep the polls open into the New Year, so all the holiday makers will gave the chance to vote.
-
@booboo said in 2022 TSF Team of the Year:
Have lawns to mow, a trip to Bundy and a game of Scrabble to finish. So this evening ...
Find an actual game m8......
-
No voting buttons for me
Here's my team
Baille
Marchand
Furlong
Etzebeth
Beirne
Lawes
Kolisi
SaveaDupont
Ntamack
Koroibete
De Allende
Am
LRZ
CapuzzoFarrell
-
@MiketheSnow said in 2022 TSF Team of the Year:
No voting buttons for me
Here's my team
Baille
Marchand
Furlong
Etzebeth
Beirne
Lawes
Kolisi
SaveaDupont
Ntamack
Koroibete
De Allende
Am
LRZ
CapuzzoFarrell
Only got 4 wrong.
-
@MiketheSnow said in 2022 TSF Team of the Year:
No voting buttons for me
Here's my team
Baille
Marchand
Furlong
Etzebeth
Beirne
Lawes
Kolisi
SaveaDupont
Ntamack
Koroibete
De Allende
Am
LRZ
CapuzzoFarrell
In the thread, go to the top and refresh it.