RWC2019 - Match officials
-
@Billy-Tell said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
Oh for the good old days of derek bevan, Jim Fleming, Wayne Erickson, Stu Dickinson and Ed Morrison.
You missed out Nigel Whitehouse...
-
Seriuosly how did France get four refs - dont think their standard of reffing is that great, and to give them four ffs.
-
@Jailbreak7 said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
Seriuosly how did France get four refs - dont think their standard of reffing is that great, and to give them four ffs.
Meanwhile Hometown misses out. I know, he's not that good but that means we don't have our ranked ref there. What gives?
-
"NZ Rugby national referee manager Bryce Lawrence was disappointed Jackson, who he said has controlled close to 500 first-class games, had been overlooked.
"We are really disappointed for Glen personally. They (World Rugby) have just decided to take younger referees to this year's World Cup. The way I am reading between the lines is that Jacko has missed out to a couple of younger guys - not only from New Zealand but other countries as well."
Jeez cos we saw how well a young Wabne Barnes did under the stress spotlight did in 07!
-
@Machpants That is a BS excuse if so. Farken gin swillers!!!
-
@canefan more so when you consider the age of those useless French fucks...hometown is the perfect ref for Japan, to ref Japan.
I guess at least with Pickerell in Japan, we wont have to put up with him at M10 Cup...although with our 'top refs' largely out of action for M10 Cup, will be a new breed of refs to come through...
-
@Rocky-Rockbottom said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
ffs Hometown thinks its some sort of service award?
I'm sure he does, it's the IRB referee panel.
-
If we are in the final and playing anyone else other than the Boks, I’d happily have Jaco ref the test.
-
@ACT-Crusader said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
If we are in the final and playing anyone else other than the Boks, I’d happily have Jaco ref the test.
Not going to happen if there is a NH team involved.
*well at least not without a load of bullshit from Stephen Jones anyway
-
-
I am delighted Brendon Pickerill has been appointed to the touch judging panel. The SANZAR Referees Appointments Manager must surely now be obilged to appoint him soley as a touch judge for Super Rugby matches to give him the best possible preparation for his role in Japan. Co-incidently it will also save us from having to witness any further displays with the whistle under his control.
-
Owens and Jaco are by far my favourite refs. Nobody will ever get everything right in such a dynamic game both those two are really a cut above IMO.
Poite and Garces are the two most ridiculous refs to ever referee at the top level.
-
-
@Stargazer said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
Referees (12):
Wayne Barnes (England)
Luke Pearce (England)
Jérôme Garcès (France)
Romain Poite (France)
Pascal Gaüzère (France)
Mathieu Raynal (France)
Nigel Owens (Wales)
Jaco Peyper (South Africa)
Ben O’Keeffe (New Zealand)
Paul Williams (New Zealand)
Nic Berry (Australia)
Angus Gardner (Australia)That's a sobering list. How is it they're the best refs the world can produce?
-
@barbarian said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
Jaco is too inconsistent for my liking. Varies wildly from game to game in terms of quality.
Owens and Barnes are my favourites, I just like their communication and their tendency to let the game flow.
I wasn't much of a fan of Jaco a few years back but more recently he's been very good IMO.
-
@barbarian said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
Jaco is too inconsistent for my liking. Varies wildly from game to game in terms of quality.
Owens and Barnes are my favourites, I just like their communication and their tendency to let the game flow.
I do have to agree with that.
Trouble with Barnes is that he has always maintained an ability to regularly produce a game changing clanger out of his pocket. 98% accurate but man that 2% was a killer.
Other refs will make more errors but ones that get discarded in the post mortem. -
@antipodean said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
@Stargazer said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
Referees (12):
Wayne Barnes (England)
Luke Pearce (England)
Jérôme Garcès (France)
Romain Poite (France)
Pascal Gaüzère (France)
Mathieu Raynal (France)
Nigel Owens (Wales)
Jaco Peyper (South Africa)
Ben O’Keeffe (New Zealand)
Paul Williams (New Zealand)
Nic Berry (Australia)
Angus Gardner (Australia)That's a sobering list. How is it they're the best refs the world can produce?
This is what shits me. According to Hometown Jackson the decision was to take a bunch of young guys to the RWC to increase their experience and benefit the future of the reffing pool.
Is that really what we want at the game showcase event?
Barnes again is the poster boy for why this approach can have a downside. Taken to the RWC for experience, he certainly got it. But at a cost. -
@Crucial said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
@Stargazer said in RWC2019 - Match officials:
Four French refs ...
They had an agreement.
A Deal?
