All Black Coach - Ian Foster
-
-
-
Toss up between Robertson and Joseph for me.
JJ has a history of taking a team of no-names and making them play like champions.
Razor has a history of taking a talented team and getting the best out of them.
Given the talent available for the ABs I went for Razor.
Would like to see Razor, JJ and Brown together though, theyve been the standouts recently.
Rennie has a very strong claim as well.
Anything outside of those four would be ridiculous.
-
@cgrant said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
England's defence has been outstanding so far. Why not Mitchell as the next defence specialist to replace McLeod ?
Good question cgrant. Look we’ve picked Joe McDonnell because he’s got explosive power. We’re on a journey to 2023.
-
-
@Tim said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Rumour circulating in NZ media circles that Robertson is the favoured candidate.
Knowing the panel who will interview and make the recommendation to the board would be a start. Tew was on Devlin saying it has been appointed and will be announced after Friday.
Interestingly he also said all the high performance NZ coaches both at home and overseas are aware of the process. Not that he seems to be a chance but Tew was coy about Gatland and to it sounded as though Gatland may have an out clause of his Lions contract for the top job.
-
This post is deleted!
-
-
@sparky gym bunnies?
Can't remember which TSF poster made that comment about the Boks...
-
@Billy-Webb said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@sparky gym bunnies?
Can't remember which TSF poster made that comment about the Boks...
There’s probably a middle ground between the Boks and the ABs forward packs - it would probably look something like the English pack.
-
@junior said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@Billy-Webb said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
@sparky gym bunnies?
Can't remember which TSF poster made that comment about the Boks...
There’s probably a middle ground between the Boks and the ABs forward packs - it would probably look something like the English pack.
My comment was tongue-in-cheek.
The Welsh pack was actually heavier than the Boks. 915kg v 900kg.
I can't swear to it, but I seem to think the AB pack also outweighs us.What works for us is the mongrel. It's why RG Snyman will have a much longer Bok career than Mostert.
But that is our DNA.
You have to find what works for you.EDIT: and to a large degree I think you have. And for a long time. Don't baby-and-bathwater after one loss
-
I've looked at the Wikipedia pages for Jamie Joseph and Scott Robertson. Robertson has had the Midas touch but seems inexperienced in comparison to Joseph and he has had the luxury of coaching the best players.
Joseph has some good victories but a lot of failure too.
He is known for his famous victory over the Hurricanes in the final but in many years the Highlanders were shit. I also think his results in the RWC must be kept in perspective. It was a great effort but Japan narrowly beat a shit Irish team and middling Scottish team with home ground advantage.
No idea who would be better.
-
@Frank said in [Poll] Next All Black Coach:
Joseph has some good victories but a lot of failure too.
You say that like it's a bad thing.
For many that is the major knock on Razor - every coach in every sport in the world will fail at some stage and would much rather see him do it on another RFU's dime and watch and see how he responds.
Smith, Hansen and Henry were a success from 2004 onwards in large part because of their very public collective failures in the early 2000s.
-
the ideal coaching team would be JJ, Razor & TB...who cares which is the head coach.
What was Scott McLeods contract? WIl he be collateral damage? Has Fox ever expressed any interest?
Can anyone convince Wayne SMith to come back?
